Citizenship practices in school spaces: comparative discourse analysis of children’s group decision making

ABSTRACT

Critique of citizenship education has suggested citizenship should be reconceived, not as a status, but as something that people continuously do: citizenship as practice. This article draws on a two-year ethnographic study of citizenship practices in a Scottish primary school examining how citizenship curriculum was distributed across children’s experience of the school day, the ways belonging was constructed in different spaces and time frames and how civic participation was identified in pupils’ own terms. The article’s close discourse analysis examines moments when children’s decision-making reveals the connections made between citizenship curriculum and viable citizenship identities in practice. This micro analysis of the semi-formal space of the school reveals children’s understanding of group cooperation that remain opaque in the more formal setting of the classroom. The findings suggest that educators would do well to attune further to children’s informal decision making processes and curricular practices that would better support them.

KEYWORDS:

• Dialogic mediated activity
• citizenship
• collaborative problem solving
• curricular practice
• group work
• discourse analysis
• speech communities

Acknowledgement

The author would like to thank the students and staff of the primary school which hosted the study and gave generously of their time. Thanks also to Jan Blommaert and Ben Rampton for their expertise and encouragement analysing the text.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).