‘A state of almost surreal vice versa’: the devolution referendums in Wales, 1979 and 1997

ABSTRACT

Referendums in 1979 and 1997 asked if an elected Assembly should be created in Wales to oversee some government responsibilities. The proportion of voters supporting devolution grew from 20.3% in 1979 to 50.3% in 1997. Growth was concentrated within Welsh identifying Labour voters, but the literature lacks a multicausal explanation of this shift. This article compares the circumstances surrounding both referendums to make two arguments. One is that three factors reversed: the dominant industrial role of the UK state receded under Conservative Governments to prompt deindustrialisation; the growing profile of Wales-specific governance structures exposed their control by Conservative politicians lacking a direct electoral mandate; and, voters were more positive towards Labour in 1997 than 1979. The other is that these factors impacted most on Welsh identifying Labour voters clustered in deindustrialising areas, who no longer trusted the UK state to represent their interests. Their class-based political identity evolved to include a greater sense of Welshness, increasing their support for devolution when offered by a trusted Labour Government. This sequence was prompted and sustained by deindustrialisation, echoing Tomlinson’s arguments that it undercut political assumptions and structures to provide the best underpinning narrative for late twentieth-century Britain.

KEYWORDS:

• Devolution
• Deindustrialisation
• Wales
• Labour party
• Constitution

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.

Notes

1. Jones and Wilford. “The Referendum Campaign,” 138; Taylor, Curtice and Thomson, “Introduction and Conclusions,” xxviii.

2. Evans and Trystan. “Why was 1997 Different?,” 101, 106.

3. Jones and Balsom. The Road to the National Assembly for Wales; Taylor and Thompson. Scotland and Wales: Nations Again?, See also Andrews, Wales Says Yes; Morgan and Mungham, Redesigning Democracy.

4. Jones and Trystan. “The 1997 Welsh Referendum Vote,” 88; Heath. ‘Were the Welsh and Scottish Referendums Second-Order Elections?”; Balsom. “Political Developments in Wales, 1979–1997,” 14.

5. Andrews, Wales Says Yes, 182–193; Morgan, Redesigning Democracy, 115–16.

6. Moon and Bratberg. “Why the Welsh Said Yes, but the Northerners No”. 318–40; Blaxland. Thatcherism and Wales: Impacts and Legacies, 148; Gooberman. ‘Welsh Office exceptionalism’. 563–83; Gooberman. ‘A very modern kind of English loneliness’. 624–650; Western Mail, 29 September 2010.

7. Johnes. Wales since 1939, 416; Wyn Jones and Larner. “Progressive home rule?,” 5.

8. Jones. “The ‘No’ Campaign: Division and Diversity,” 73. Melding served later as Deputy Presiding Officer at the National Assembly.

9. Tomlinson. “De-industrialisation not decline”. 76–99.

10. Rhodri Morgan, ‘Ten Years of Devolution, Reflections of a First Minister’. Welsh Political Archive Annual Lecture, 2008, 4.

11. Aitchison and Carter. “The Welsh Language 1921–1991”. 44.

12. Williams. What I Came to Say, 66.

13. Jones, “The state of the nation”. 14–20.

14. Robert Liñeira. “Valence secession? Voting shocks and independence support in Scotland”. Politics and Governance, 399.

15. Edwards and Tanner. “Defining or dividing the nation?” 68; McCrone, The Sociology of Nationalism.

16. Balsom., Madgwick, van Mechelen. “The red and the green”. 323–325.

17. House of Commons Research Briefing, UK Election Statistics: 1918–2021: A century of elections (London: 2021) supporting document CBP7529, 1 GE Wales [online] available via https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-7529/

18. Balsom. “The Three-Wales Model,” 1–17.

19. Scully and Wyn Jones. “Still Three Wales?” 656.

20. O’Leary. “Of devolution, maps and divided mentalities”. 7–13.

21. Wyn Jones and Trystan. “The 1997 Welsh referendum vote”. 74.

22. Scully and Wyn Jones. “Still Three Wales?” 662.

23. Evans and Trystan. “Why was 1997 different?” 105–107.

24. Scully and Wyn Jones. “Still Three Wales?” 666.

25. Smith. Aneurin Bevan and the World of South Wales.

26. Johnes. “A Prince, a King, and a referendum”. 146.

27. Johnes. “Wales, History and Britishness”. 607.

28. Roberts. “Welsh identity in a former mining valley”. 77–95; Adamson. “The new working class and political change in Wales”.

29. Edwards. ‘Everyday, When I Wake Up, I Thank the Lord I’m Welsh’. 142–60.

30. Humphreys. Industrial Britain: South Wales, 64.

31. Williams. Digest of Welsh Historical Statistics, 1974–1996, 90–1.

32. Williams. Digest of Welsh Historical Statistics, Vol. II, 299–300.

33. Welsh Office. Welsh Economic Trends 6, 16; Fevre, Wales is Closed, 17, 23.

34. Digest of Welsh Statistics 25, 127; Digest of Welsh Statistics 29, 133.

35. Welsh Office. Welsh Economic Trends 6, 16, 21.

36. Office for National Statistics, New Earning Survey 1979, Part E, Table E25.

37. National Library of Wales (NLW), John Morris Papers, 2/15, Wales Needs an Elected Assembly [undated]; Port Talbot Guardian, 22 February 1979, 10.

38. NLW, Labour Party, 216, Labour No to the Assembly leaflet [undated]; Labour No Assembly Campaign, Facts to Beat Fantasies (Blackwood, 1979), 49.

39. Wilford. “The Character of the Lobbies,” 116; Western Mail, 11 January 1979, 6.

40. NLW, Labour Party, 216, Labour Party Wales Press Release, 26 February 1979.

41. NLW, Crickhowell Papers, 3/12. Speech to Gower Conservative Association, 17 November 1979.

42. Fevre. Wales is Closed, 25; Smith. A Century of Shotton Steel, 64; Welsh Government, Statswales.

43. Francis. History on Our Side, 54–55, 65.

44. Digest of Welsh Historical Statistics, Vol. II, 138–139. Data adjusted to remove employment in the steel industry.

45. Invest in Britain/UK Trade and Investment FDI project database.

46. Office of National Statistics, seasonally adjusted claimant count via NOMIS; Interview with Rhodri Morgan, MP for Cardiff West (1987–2001), Front Bench Spokesman on Welsh Affairs (1992–1997), First Minister (2001–2009), 13 December 2011.

47. The National Archives (TNA), WA 8/54, WDA Board Papers, 20 May 1980.

48. TNA, 8/168, WDA Strategic Review, July 1990.

49. Office for National Statistics, New Earning Survey 1997, Part E, Tables E25, E26.

50. NLW, Ron Davies Papers, 79, Incomes in Mid-Glamorgan, Mid-Glamorgan County Council, 1994, 9; Morris and Wilkinson, Poverty and Prosperity in Wales, 65.

51. Interview with Ron Davies, Labour MP for Caerphilly (1983–2001), Shadow Secretary of State for Wales (1992–1997); Secretary of State for Wales (1997–1999), 7 March 2011.

52. NLW, Labour Party S/37, The Economic Case for A Welsh Assembly, 1996, 3.

53. UK Governemnt. A Voice for Wales, 11.

54. Jones. “The ‘No’ Campaign: Division and Diversity,” 92.

55. Morris. Fifty Years in Politics and the Law, 109.

56. Jones. The Education of a Nation, 145.

57. Observer, 30 October 1966, 12.

58. Port Talbot Guardian, 25 January 1979, 4.

59. NLW, John Morris Papers 2/15, Statement by John Morris, Secretary of State for Wales, February 1979, 3–4.

60. NLW, Labour Party, 216, BBC Wales Poll, February 1979.

61. Morris. Fifty Years in Politics and the Law, 110.

62. Western Mail, 23 February 1979, 13.

63. Morgan. Welsh Political Archive Lecture, Rhai Atgofion Gwleidyddol, 21; Western Mail, 20 February 1979, 9.

64. NLW, John Morris Papers 2/15, Statement by John Morris, February 1979, 4.

65. Gooberman. “Welsh Office exceptionalism”. Contemporary British History.

66. Welsh Development Agency, Wales: The Inward Investment Story.

67. Edwards, Tanner, and Carlin. “The Conservative governments and the development of Welsh language policy”. 529–51.

68. Aitchison and Carter. “The Welsh language in Cardiff”. 482–492.

69. Aitchison and Carter. “The Welsh Language Today”. 94.

70. Morgan and Roberts. Democratic Deficit, A Guide to Quangoland, 23.

71. NLW, Wyn Roberts Diary, 18 January 1994.

72. NLW, Ron Davies Papers, 81, The Cost of Unaccountability, September 1994, 2.

73. Wyn Roberts. Right From the Start (Cardiff, 2006), 133.

74. UK Election Statistics: 1918–2021.

75. Nicholas Crickhowell. Westminster, Wales, and Water, 51.

76. NLW, Crickhowell Papers 1/5, Copy of Letter to John Wakeham, Chief Whip [1985].

77. Williams. Guilty Men, 52.

78. Independent, 1 July 1995; Western Mail, 3 July 1993, 3.

79. NLW, Wyn Roberts Diary, 21 June 1995.

80. Interview with Leighton Andrews, co-founder and deputy convenor of the ‘Yes for Wales’ campaign, 11 March 2019. Andrews, Wales Says Yes, 96-97.

81. Western Mail, 28 November 2018.

82. Western Mail, 27 August 1997.

83. Morgan. Rhodri, 118.

84. NLW, Labour Party S/37, Just Say No Leaflet ‘What will a Welsh Assembly do for you?’, 1997.

85. Edwards. Hewn from the Rock, 6.

86. Parliamentary Debates (Commons), vol. 885, 3 February 1975, cc 1031.

87. Wiliam. “Labour, the union, and the rebirth of Welsh devolution,” 232.

88. Western Mail, 22 January 1979; South Wales Echo, 21 February 1979, 1; 28 February, 1.

89. Morris. Fifty Years in Politics and the Law, 124; Interview with Eurfyl ap Gwilym, Plaid Cymru Director of Research (1973–1977), National Chairman (1977–1981), 15 May 2011.

90. NLW, John Morris Papers 2/15, Minute to the Prime Minister, Assessment of the state of the Devolution Campaign, 14 February 1979, 3.

91. For example, see South Wales Echo, 21 February 1979, 8.

92. Labour No Assembly Campaign, Facts to Beat Fantasies. 1.

93. Donoughue. Downing Street Diary, Volume II, 121.

94. NLW, Labour Party 2/6, Referendum Meetings, February 1979.

95. NLW, John Morris Papers 2/15, Minute to the Prime Minister, Assessment of the state of the Devolution Campaign, 14 February 1979, 2.

96. UK Election Statistics: 1918–2021

97. Davies. Devolution, A Process and not an Event, 4.

98. Blair. A Journey 251.

99. Western Mail, 1 March 1995, 9; Western Mail, 6 May 1995, 1; UK Election Statistics: 1918–2021.

100. Western Mail, 10 September 1997, 1.

101. Evans and Trystan. “Why was 1997 Different?,” 105.

102. Andrews. Wales Says Yes, 92–93.

103. Interview with Leighton Andrews, 11 March 2019; TNA, PREM 49/21, Briefing Note for Prime Minister, 11 September 1997.

104. TNA, PREM 49/20, Note from the Prime Minister, 18 July 1997, 6; The Times, 19 July 1997; Western Mail, 17 September 1997, 3.

105. Roberts. Right From the Start, 330–331.

106. Jones. “The ‘No’ Campaign: Division and Diversity,” 73.

107. Evans and Trystan. “Why was 1997 Different?,” 112.

108. TNA, PREM 49/18, Note of Meeting with Lord Chancellor, 5 May 1997; Western Mail, 15 September 1997, 1.

109. Johnes. Wales since 1939, 416; Wyn Jones and Larner. “Progressive home rule?,” 5.

110. Tomlinson. “De-industrialisation not decline,” 99.

111. Balsom, “The Referendum Result,” 153, 159.

112. Balsom, “The Referendum Result,” 159.

113. King. Brittle with Relics, 731.