Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent social isolation measures had a profound impact on communities worldwide. In regional and remote Western Australia, the use of online platforms has become increasingly important for maintaining social and emotional well-being. This article examines the role of ‘The Isolation Tour 2020’ Facebook page in providing a lifeline for its mostly Aboriginal audience to stay connected with culture, Country, and one another during the 2020 COVID-19 lockdown in Western Australia. The authors conducted an in-depth interview with one of the administrators of the page and supplemented this with a thematic analysis of publicly available Facebook data. Data were analysed using NVivo qualitative analysis software and common themes were identified. The findings show that ‘The Isolation Tour 2020’ provided an effective virtual platform for people to interact with loved ones and feel a sense of belonging and comfort in the uncertainty of the pandemic. This research highlights the importance of online spaces for supporting social and emotional well-being during extended periods of social isolation and offers insights into how similar initiatives can be supported in future.
Introduction
Hey guys …welcome to the Isolation tour. Lets keep the music going.... any artists who would like to join our Live events let us know and we’ll put on a concert from our lounge/bath/toilet/roof/bed…wherever u want lol. (The Isolation Tour Facebook page, post 5, ‘Hey guys …welcome to the Isolation tour,’ 21 March 2020)Footnote1
Each weekend during the strictest social isolation period in Western Australia, the ‘Isolation Tour 2020’Footnote2 Facebook page (hereafter ‘the Tour’ and ‘the Tour page’) hosted a virtual music tour for a socially isolated, mostly Aboriginal audience. During this six-week period, artists and musicians on the Tour page produced more than fifty-three hours of live video footage, which garnered thousands of live comments, thousands of shares, and tens of thousands of views. This article explores the process and impact of organizing, hosting, and managing the Tour as an important cultural event during the COVID-19 pandemic. In particular, we focus on the way that the Tour page became a lifeline for Indigenous communities to stay connected with culture, Country,Footnote3 and one another during this extended period of social isolation. We situate this within a broader context of grassroots initiatives in the arts to develop and maintain creative communities amid calls for greater funding and government support (Boland Citation2020a, Citation2020b; Terzon Citation2020; Burke Citation2022; Freeland and Reich Citation2022; Morris Citation2022; Eltham Citation2022).
Studies conducted since the beginning of the pandemic indicate that the psychosocial effects of social isolation measures disproportionately impacted minority communities, including Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples (Newby et al. Citation2020; Bennett, Uink, and Cross Citation2020). For Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, the relationship between cultural and community connectedness and social and emotional well-being is well established in the literature (Gee et al. Citation2014; Dudgeon et al. Citation2017; Farnbach et al. Citation2018). Thus, maintaining a sense of connectedness is especially critical for these groups during the pandemic and any future crises. In a study of online social connection at the height of major restrictions in Australia, Stuart et al. (Citation2021, 524) found that ‘using potentially compensatory forms of online social connection can be beneficial (or at least, alleviate negative outcomes) for those who may be the most at-risk (highly health anxious and isolated).’ Studies show that digital technologies and social media platforms such as Facebook effectively support social and emotional well-being for Indigenous peoples, as they afford means of staying connected with family, friends, culture, and Country (Healy Citation2013; Lumby Citation2010; Vaarzon-Morel Citation2014; Hensel et al. Citation2019). For this reason, Walker et al. (Citation2021) argue that tailored online and social media strategies are urgently needed during extended periods of social isolation, distress, and anxiety, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, to promote positive social and emotional well-being and resilience among Indigenous peoples. We argue that the Isolation Tour 2020 afforded community and cultural connectedness during the strictest social restrictions of the COVID-19 pandemic in Western Australia.
Following a methodological description of our study, we proceed in part one to outline the conditions of social isolation in Western Australia that led two administrators (hereafter ‘admins’) to start the Tour page. Part two discusses the challenges admins faced as the audience grew into the thousands, including managing their workload, technological demands, and encouraging more women to participate as performers, and how they addressed these challenges. Part three explores how the Tour community transformed the admins’ original vision and became a beloved meeting place for artists and audiences to stay connected to community, Country, and culture during lockdown, and showcases this process through a small case study of a virtual tribute show hosted on the Tour page.
Background
Both admins of the page are Western Australian Aboriginal singer-songwriters who experienced significant downturn in public performance engagements because of government-imposed public health restrictions. As such, the two admins took it upon themselves to create opportunities for themselves and their peers despite a lack of support from the government and institutions. Before establishing the Tour page, neither had prior experience in facilitating online performances. Our interviewee, one of the two admins of the page, is a well-known member of the Noongar community, the largest Aboriginal cultural bloc in Western Australia, covering its southwest corner including the capital city of Perth and comprising upwards of 30,000 people. The Noongar region was the first area in Western Australia to face British colonization in the early nineteenth century and is dominated by urban and agricultural development today. Despite being subjected to many decades of cultural assimilation policies and practices, Noongar have sustained strong and distinctive cultural identities through the maintenance of kin relationships, and involvement in activism and performance (Kickett-Tucker and Hansen Citation2016; Haebich Citation2018; Bracknell et al. Citation2021).
Methods
To understand the process and impact of hosting a virtual online Tour for Aboriginal performing artists, we conducted a qualitative in-depth interview with one of the two admins of the Tour page to understand their motivations for creating and managing the page, as well as the various challenges they faced managing the expectations of the emergent community surrounding the Tour page. Written consent to participate was obtained before the recorded interview commenced.
We supplemented the interview with interactive and public Facebook data. We found that the live videos, which are still available at the time of writing,Footnote4 best captured artists’ and admins’ sentiments about the function and value of the page, expressed in real time and with familiarity and candour despite the public, visible platform of the Tour page. The full dataset included the following:
metadata for all admin posts to the page from the inception of the page (21 March 2020) to the end of the Tour (2 May 2020); all posts within this time frame were numbered chronologically from ‘1’ to ‘281’ and categorized (e.g., ‘text post’ or ‘live video’), including time and date of posts, and reaction data such as number of comments and likes (as of June 2021);
metadata from live videos such as real-time comments and reaction data from other users;
transcripts of all live videos on the first official day of the Tour, including corresponding real-time comments from viewers;
a transcript of the final two-hour ‘Last Hurrah’ video by the admins, including corresponding real-time comments from viewers;
all real-time comments from the most viewed live video of the Tour, a tribute show for a prominent Noongar performer and artist who passed away during the Tour period;
all real-time comments from the second-last video of the Tour; and
all text post data posted by the admins during the Tour period and corresponding comments from users.
All transcriptions were completed by the first author. The first author analysed data using NVivo12 qualitative analysis software and identified prevalent themes using thematic analysis (Braun and Clarke Citation2006). All authors met regularly to cross-check and discuss themes arising to ensure the validity of the findings.
Part One: Increased Social Isolation
In 2020, the Western Australia’s McGowan government outlined its plan to eliminate—rather than suppress—community transmission of COVID-19. Central to this approach were stay-at-home orders that restricted social interaction between households. In Western Australia, the strictest ‘Stage 1’ of these restrictions was widely referred to as a ‘lockdown’ and lasted between 23 March and 27 April 2020 (McNeill Citation2020). During this period, all gatherings of more than two people and all non-essential trips outside the home were banned, with no indication of how long the bans would last. The Isolation Tour 2020 ran during this period, from 21 March until the week after Stage 1 restrictions lifted. After 27 April, the Western Australia’s McGowan government brought in Stage 2 of easing trips outside the home (Pilat and Hastie Citation2020). Most other restrictions were eased by 6 June 2020.
Usher et al. (Citation2020) warn of the potential mental health impacts of social distancing and isolation among Indigenous peoples in Australia (2020), and an Australia-wide study into acute mental health responses at the peak of the national COVID-19 lockdown (Newby et al. Citation2020) found that Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander status correlated with higher levels of anxiety and distress during this time. Perrin et al. (Citation2009) stress minority groups’ heightened susceptibility to psychological harm during periods of crisis prior to the coronavirus pandemic. Considering the elevated risks to Indigenous mental health due to the pandemic, digital technologies and social media platforms provided a crucial lifeline for these communities to maintain a sense of connection to family, culture, and community networks (Walker et al. Citation2021; Healy Citation2013; Lumby Citation2010; Vaarzon-Morel Citation2014).
Musicians and artists Australia-wide also experienced significant financial challenges throughout the COVID-19 lockdown periods, as concerts, tours, and gigs were summarily cancelled without remuneration. For one of the Tour admins, a musician, this resulted in significant psychological distress:
My experience was at first really sad because I had a whole … WA tour locked in and I lost a whole lot, which I pre-sold every show, so, it was gonna be a huge year for us … after finding out that, you know, feeling down, depressed, you know, anxiety started kicking in and things like that. (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020)
The admins predominantly utilized the Facebook live video feature, initially on their own personal accounts, and then coming together on the dedicated Isolation Tour Facebook page. As both admins indicated in early live videos to viewers:
Instead of having to chase the different artists around we can bring ’em all to one page and go from there. Keep the music going. (The Isolation Tour, transcript of live video [Admin 2], post 8, 21 March 2020)
So yeh let’s keep this going, let’s share the love, because there was people performing all over Western Australia here tonight and we had it all here you know, sittin’ back. (The Isolation Tour, transcript of live video [Admin 1], post 10, 21 March 2020)
Part Two: Barriers to Participation in the Isolation Tour 2020
Admins, artists, and audiences faced several challenges to participating fully in the Isolation Tour 2020. First and foremost were the administrative, technological, and logistical complexities that the admins faced in managing the page. The two admins provided technical support to artists ‘going live’ on the page, and as the page increased in popularity, their workload became unmanageable, with an ever-increasing number of contributors—including solo singer/guitarists, rappers, duos, and people singing karaoke to backing tracks—requiring advice and assistance. To try to limit this workload, they decided to raise the bar for artists to perform as part of the Tour and divert the karaoke-style performers to a separate page. An unintended consequence of this decision was a decline in women participating in the Tour as artists, as women’s primary mode of participating until that point was through the medium of karaoke. Another significant barrier to access was the digital literacy required to utilize the live video feature, which initially inhibited some artists from participating. Poor Internet connectivity also required some audiences to rely on expensive mobile data. We explore these challenges below.
Even though both admins had some prior experience going live from their own personal music pages on Facebook, they faced challenges hosting the ongoing online performances, due to technological difficulties and the time intensity of setting up and monitoring each live video performance. Prior to the Tour, Admin 1 had used the live video feature ‘just for updates and things like this’ (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020), not for a large-scale music event. As such, Admin 1 struggled with the technological demands of the Tour, particularly during the lockdown. When asked ‘how did you go about navigating the technological side of things?,’ he responded:
Horrible … we Googled a lot of things ‘what’s the best way to plug it in to your computer via your mixing desk,’ and ‘what microphones are best to use’ so [Admin 2] and I both ‘invested’ [laughs] … we was both going out to the shops and trying this and trying that until we got it, and then we started to—with other people that was coming online and playing and that, you know—we just made suggestions to them, you know, so ‘you should set this up, that up,’ and quite a few of them did, as well. (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020)
It was very, very exhausting and, you know, the first few times [Admin 2] and I was going back and forth tryin’ to do it, but you’re sitting there sometimes for five hours, but what about our kids? You know? It was our families as well, and we’re in lockdown, so we was trying to balance that side of things. (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020)
Without [Admin 2] stepping up to the plate like that, there’s no way I could have kept up with it, but he … you gotta have that team, you know? You gotta have a team, whether it’s one or two of you or five or seven of you. But [Admin 2], yeh, he made sure it was punctual, making sure people’s quality was there. (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020)
Hope you guys enjoyed last night. It was an epic 5 hour show....... only problem it was all blokes.......
So here’s a shout out to all our talented and awesome ladies.... like the commercial said… ‘where the bloody hell are ya’
We’re trying to set up a Sunday sesh for this afternoon…. please tag any of our awesome ladies to participate.....
If anyone is interested just message the page and we’ll get it set up.....
We don’t care if it’s with an instrument or karaoke style… let’s keep the music rolling
Also… please please share this page to all your friends.... it’s costs u nothing…. maybe except some data.... . (The Isolation Tour, post 28, ‘Hope you guys enjoyed last night,’ 22 March 2020)
At the time of this posting, the page had fewer than 1000 likes. Commenters on the post tagged one another, encouraging their sisters and ‘grannies’ (grandchildren) to participate, mostly through karaoke:
[Name tag] wanna join tonight? I will come record u from karaoke? (5 replies)
[3 name tags] cmon ladies join the tour, loves it!! (3 likes)
[Name tag] kareoke style (1 laugh react, 2 replies)
[Name tag] gone sis (2 likes)
[Name tag] your grannies? (2 likes). (The Isolation Tour, comments, post 28, ‘Hope you guys enjoyed last night,’ 22 March 2020)
Good morning awesome people.
So we’re going to change the format of the page just to get back in line of what is was created for. To support artists who have lost all of their opportunities to perform publicly during these hard times.
*Starting next week we will only be doing shows from artists who want to perform live starting—
Thursday—8–10pm
Friday & Saturday—8pm–Midnight
*Sunday Session—4–6pm
Unfortunately we won’t be doing karaoke live but happy to upload videos for a short period.
Sorry if this causes any inconvenience. We’ll test this new format from next week and see how it goes. Happy for you to provide feedback.
Hope you’re enjoying your day and keep the music going. (The Isolation Tour, post 87, ‘Good morning awesome people,’ 26 March 2020)
Participants’ reliance on public digital infrastructure such as the National Broadband Network (NBN) revealed shortcomings of the NBN throughout the lifespan of the Tour. Some users had to rely on expensive mobile data to participate in the Tour, as one commenter noted:
You guys have been amazing. But can you sing im running out off credit. (The Isolation Tour, comment on live video, post 281, ‘The Last Hurrah,’ 2 May 2020)
A key barrier to participation for older artists was the level of digital literacy required to utilize the Facebook live feature. Digital literacy is generally lower among older adults (Hargittai and Dobransky Citation2017), and this exacerbates feelings of social isolation and disconnection from others for this age group. This was initially a hurdle for a much-loved elder musician who was hesitant to engage due to his self-perception as technologically incapable. When he was tagged in the live video comments by family and friends encouraging him to also go live and perform, he replied with ‘I’m enjoying kicking back and listening plus I wouldn’t know how get on, technically challenged’ (The Isolation Tour, comment on live video, post 12, ‘Kenny Rogers tribute,’ 21 March 2020). Family and friends replied to his comment, promising to help him set up his sound and video equipment. He went on to become a regular headliner of the Tour and his videos proved to be some of the most popular of the entire Tour, demonstrating how the Tour community addressed apparent needs through utilizing their own networks and resources.
Part Three: How the Tour Created Community and Cultural Connectedness
As the Tour page grew and as admins and users of the page addressed and overcame challenges to access, the page became meaningful to audiences and artists in ways that the admins did not anticipate when they originally set out to provide a platform to ‘keep the music going.’ Moreover, ‘keep the music going’ took on additional meanings as audiences embraced the page as a place to come together and keep spirits lifted during social isolation, especially when the Tour community lost a prominent musician from the south-west live music scene in April.
Showcasing Local Aboriginal Talent
Admins and commenters reflected on some unexpected outcomes of The Isolation Tour in their ‘Last Hurrah’ video, posted on the final night of the Tour, 2 May 2020. These outcomes included the platforming of new and unique artists, and how this exposure cultivated senses of community pride. For audiences, artists, and admins, the page provided a platform to showcase Western Australian talent that had previously flown under the radar:
The page allowed me to find out more about the awesome talent out there that I haven’t even heard of … and to get to see you all a little more one to one … Cheers to all of you.. . (The Isolation Tour, comment on live video, post 281, ‘The Last Hurrah,’ 2 May 2020)
This has been so great showcasing all this fantastic Aboriginal talent—good on you [names of admins] for your initiative to showcase this ♥. (The Isolation Tour, comment on live video, post 280, ‘The Last Hurrah,’ 2 May 2020)
Admin 1: That’s been one of the best things about this Isolation Tour is hearing people do songs their way.
Admin 2: Yeh. And it’s cool because a lot of the artists who come on did that. (The Isolation Tour, transcript of live video, post 281, ‘The Last Hurrah,’ 2 May 2020)
Thank you to all the artist who brought us entertainment during this Covid19 lock down, I’m very proud of our Indigenous talent out there. (The Isolation Tour, comment, post 239, ‘*Important Notice*,’ 27 April 2020)
Thanks guys our very own deadly Aboriginal Entertainers . (The Isolation Tour, comment on live video, post 281, ‘The Last Hurrah,’ 2 May 2020)
Participants also frequently used Noongar language words and Aboriginal English. A word frequency query of the Tour dataset highlighted words such as ‘moorditj’ (strong, excellent), ‘nyorn’ (expressing sympathy), ‘yorga’ (woman), ‘deadly’ and ‘solid’ (excellent). The prevalence of ‘moorditj,’ ‘solid,’ and ‘deadly’ also demonstrates the audience’s tendency to support and embrace artists who featured on the Tour, rather than to critique or ridicule (comments of this nature were virtually non-existent). The widespread use of Noongar and Aboriginal English on the Tour page reinforces individuals’ sense of a shared cultural and community identity, which contributes to social and emotional well-being (Gee et al. Citation2014). The importance of providing a positive online space is illustrated by the following comment on one of the final ‘Last Hurrah’ live videos:
This is a unique situation days that connect family n people across our nation that really felt connected. Thank you for your time n effort [names of admins], I’m sure it comes especially from our wa People. So much talent here that’s guys xx well done n will miss isolation tour 2020. (The Isolation Tour, comment on live video, post 281, ‘The Last Hurrah,’ 2 May 2020)
Language is central to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures. The two are intertwined. Language describes cultural attachment to place, cultural heritage items, and puts meaning within the many cultural activities that people do. Furthermore, language plays a fundamental part in binding communities together as a culture, and individuals to each other in a society.
Cultivating Interactivity through Consistency and Lo-Fi Production Values
Requests constituted a substantial portion of the activity in the comments section for live videos, as demonstrated by the following interaction between an artist and a frequent commenter. During one live video, the male artist, after hearing a notification alarm from a nearby digital device, asks a woman off-camera ‘who’s that?’ The woman off-camera replies ‘it’s a request’ in the comments of the video they are streaming. The artist looks at the device and reads the comment aloud, ‘Sing [the song] Illusion?,’ and turns back to the camera to say ‘aw, look out.’ A second woman off-camera says of the commenter ‘that’s Aunty [name].’ The artist contemplates playing it for a moment and then says, ‘I might sing Illusions next, see how I go’ (The Isolation Tour, transcript of live video [Artist 4],Footnote8 post 25, 21 March 2020).
This example is typical of many interactions between artists and audiences throughout the life of the Tour, and many artists would make a clear effort to keep one eye on the comments of their video as they were streaming live. The comments also provided real-time feedback on any potential audio-visual issues (‘sound [is] a little low,’ or ‘It’s working bro’), or to provide support and positive feedback (‘Too Deadly Uncle,’ ‘Perfect bro,’ ‘Moorditj brother,’ ‘Beautiful voice beautiful song well done,’ or ‘Too deadly’). Indeed, ‘hyping up’ artists like this as they were performing was the predominant theme in comments throughout the whole Tour and contributed to the overall positive atmosphere of the Tour page.
As indicated, the Facebook platform allowed for a high degree of user-to-user interactivity (as opposed to the user-to-system interactivity of the AI-generated news feed), which contributed to high feelings of connectedness to one another:
And I think that what people found comforting as well is that they can talk live to somebody at the same time [in] the live comments, and people was making requests and was having that interaction. (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020)
I think people found comfort in it, because, you know, obviously things were up in the air, you didn’t know what you could do and what you couldn’t do, but they knew that we was on that night, it was on every night … and I think that’s what people found that comfort in and they can rely on it, because at the time, when the world was confused, they knew that we was on live every night and we were singin’ songs. … It wasn’t a lot of our best performances or anything like that, but it was something. It was something that people could rely on.… If we say we’re gonna have this artist, and that artist, we make sure we have them.… It was that … routine. (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020)
Sad to hear it’s the last night.. This isolation tour was a great thing for all our mob and all over especially when you going through difficult times.. thank you [names of admins] and all the artists. I enjoyed some of the songs with tears, and gave comfort listening through this isolation tour.. thanks for the entertainment.. (The Isolation Tour, comment, post 279, 2 May 2020)
It brought tears and a little comfort to me for my difficult time, listening to this isolation tour. (The Isolation Tour, comment on live video, post 281, ‘The Last Hurrah,’ 2 May 2020)
If someone’s just sitting there with their phone and singing to it like that, they’re singing to you, you know, you’re not thinking about everyone else that’s tuned in, this person is singing to you, because that’s your phone you’re holding there, and that’s where that intimacy comes from and that connection. (Admin 1 interview, 14 October 2020)
Case Study: The Tribute Show
As discussed in part one, the Tour provided a crucial lifeline for these communities to maintain a sense of connection to family, culture, and community networks. This was especially apparent when a well-known Noongar performer and artist passed away about one month into the Stage 1 lockdown restrictions. With permission from her family, the admins hosted a tribute show on the page in her memory the following week, which provided a significant means of maintaining community support, processing grief, and expressing condolences. The last performance of the night by two of her prior bandmates, both favourites of the Tour up until that point, is the most-watched video of the Tour.
As the Noongar performer’s friends and family were not allowed to gather for a funeral, this final live video of the tribute show held special significance for viewers. Audiences engaged by tagging family into the comments and sending condolences on behalf of their families from across Australia. The 938 comments expressed a mixture of grief, support for the family, and gratitude to the two performers who hosted the tribute from Quairiding, Western Australia, some utilizing both Aboriginal English and Noongar language:
To My Family in Quairading Love you all and thinking of you through this hard time, wish we could be with you, broken hearted feeling empty love [names] in Karratha
Heartwarming to hear all these songs. Can see her standing right there singing
Absolutely beautiful tribute ❤ Condolences to all the family at this sad time…
It’s solid to see such a wonderful tribute for a deadly yorga who will be dearly missed ❤
Loving this, wish I was there with you all
Means So Much as we can’t be with our Loved ones. Watching from Adelaide we appreciate it
What a wonderful way to share memories
[Name tag] last song
[reply] beautiful ah darl her fav . (The Isolation Tour, comments on live video, post 232, [live tribute show], 26 April 2020)
Artists who performed as part of the Tour agreed that it afforded an innovative way to stay connected and support musicians, as did audiences who tuned in to the live Tour videos:
As mob we kinda live in isolation as it is when we’re not with our community. I think this is a really special way for us to stay connected and keep our love and support going through, especially for musicians and artists who still need that support and wanna give back to community as well so, thanks you mob for havin’ a listen. (The Isolation Tour, transcript of live video [Artist 3], post 13, 21 March 2020)
Thank you so much for keeping the music alive for so many musicians—and thanks for having us . (The Isolation Tour, comment, post 239, ‘*Important Notice*,’ 27 April 2020)
Oh, that’s sad, I really enjoyed listening in to the Isolation Concert, thank you for your time in entertaining us with your music. I would just like to wish all Artist the best for the future. I was introduced to a lot of Indigenous singers whom I’ve never heard before. Thanks again, stay safe and keep those hands washed . (The Isolation Tour, comment, post 239, ‘*Important Notice*,’ 27 April 2020)
Conclusion
The Isolation Tour 2020 helped to maintain community and cultural connectedness by providing an effective virtual platform for people to meet and feel a sense of belonging during the COVID-19 pandemic. The central focus of this virtual meeting place was live music, and the initial goal of the Tour page was to ‘keep the music going’ for the musicians and artists whose livelihoods were threatened by lockdown measures. ‘Keeping the music going’ took on additional meanings as the Tour page grew and audiences embraced the page as a positive space to keep their spirits lifted, be changed by new musical experiences, and feel a sense of routine and comfort in the uncertainty of the pandemic. Initiatives such as the Isolation Tour thus provide a model for how online spaces can be utilized to support social and emotional well-being during extended periods of social isolation (Walker et al. Citation2021).
It is important to note that the Isolation Tour 2020 was Aboriginal-led and owned from its inception. The two Aboriginal singer-songwriters who created and maintained the page for their communities did so despite a lack of government and institutional support. This Aboriginal ownership of the Isolation Tour 2020 made it far more effective in building genuine community connectedness than any external top-down intervention could, as studies have previously shown (see Dudgeon et al. Citation2012). By the same reasoning, if the state government was to support similar online music resources in future, this would mean supporting the artists and admins who make it happen.
Ethics
Ethics approval for this study was obtained from the Edith Cowan University Human Research Ethics Committee under approval number 2020-01711-BRACKNELL.
Acknowledgements
The authors acknowledge Noongar Country, where this research took place, and Noongar elders past and present. They also acknowledge the generous contribution of Admin 1 to the development of this article.
Declaration of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest in the preparation of this article.
Data Availability Statement
Some data that support the findings of this study are publicly available at the time of writing. These data were derived from the following resources available in the public domain: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100064033173683.
Additional information
Funding
Notes on contributors
Brigitta Scarfe
Brigitta Scarfe is a gardiya PhD student at Kurongkurl Katitjin and the Western Australian Academy of Performing Arts, Edith Cowan University, and a descendant of Irish and English immigrants. Her doctoral research investigates Aboriginal women’s empowerment through community radio and amateur musicking practices in the West Kimberley region.
Amy Budrikis
Amy Budrikis is a wadjela Research Adviser at Kurongkurl Katitjin (Centre for Indigenous Australian Education and Research) at Edith Cowan University in Perth, Western Australia. She has a broad range of research interests from language revitalisation and historical linguistics to public health and social change.
Clint Bracknell
Clint Bracknell FAHA is a Noongar song-maker and Professor of Music at the University of Western Australia. He investigates connections between song, language, and landscapes, works on projects to improve Indigenous community access to cultural heritage collections, and releases music under the name Maatakitj.
Notes
1 Original spelling and punctuation have been retained throughout all quotations from posts on The Isolation Tour Facebook page.
2 The Tour page was initially labelled ‘2020’ but was renamed ‘2021’ the following year to maintain relevance and as the page admins organized live, in-person music tours throughout Western Australia. It remains ‘The Isolation Tour 2021’ at the time of writing. Subsequent citations of text from the page will be to ‘The Isolation Tour.’
3 Capitalized in Aboriginal contexts, Country is ‘nourishing terrain,’ alive and intertwined with Indigenous identities and knowledge systems (Rose Citation1996, 1).
4 Now renamed ‘The Isolation Tour 2021,’ the Facebook live videos are viewable online. Accessed 29 July 2023. https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100064033173683&sk=videos.
5 The Restart Investment and Sustain and Expand (RISE) was a federal government ‘emergency’ stimulus response targeted to the arts industry programmes and producers (see Pennington and Eltham Citation2021, 32).
6 NAIDOC (National Aboriginal and Islander Day Observance Committee) week is held in the first week of July, and National Reconciliation Week is held between 27 May and 3 June each year (see https://www.naidoc.org.au and https://www.reconciliation.org.au).
7 The reasons for women participating more often through karaoke than as instrumentalists reflect broader (national, global) trends whereby instrumental music is male dominated, thus limiting women’s access to these modes of music participation (Barney Citation2007; Doubleday Citation2008).
8 This numbering system was used to differentiate between unique artists and admins.
9 Aboriginal people throughout Australia use the term ‘Sorry Business’ to describe various practices related to death, mourning, and funerals.
References
- Barney, Katelyn. 2007. ‘Sending a Message: How Indigenous Australian Women Use Contemporary Music Recording Technologies to Provide a Space for Agency, Viewpoints and Agendas.’ World of Music 49, no. 1: 105–24. http://www.jstor.org/stable/41699742
- Bennett, Rebecca, Bep Uink, and Sam Cross. 2020. ‘Beyond the Social: Cumulative Implications of COVID-19 for First Nations University Students in Australia.’ Social Sciences & Humanities Open 2, no. 1: 100083. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2020.100083
- Boland, Michaela. 2020a. ‘Coronavirus Shuts Down Live Music and Arts Industry, Leaders Call for $850m Stimulus Package.’ ABC News, 17 March 2020. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-03-17/coronavirus-covid19-live-music-arts-funding-stimulus-package/12064320
- Boland, Michaela. 2020b. ‘Arts Sector Hit Again as La Mama Theatre, Sydney Writers’ Festival and Others Lose Australia Council Funding Amid Coronavirus Shutdown.’ ABC News, 6 April 2020. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-04-03/arts-theatre-companies-australia-council-funding/12119924
- Bracknell, Clint. 2019. ‘Identity, Language and Collaboration in Indigenous Music.’ In The Difference Identity Makes: Indigenous Cultural Capital in Australian Cultural Fields, edited by Lawrence Bamblett, Fred Myers, and Tim Rowse, 99–123. Canberra, ACT: Aboriginal Studies Press.
- Bracknell, Clint, Kylie Bracknell, Susan Fenty Studham, and Luzita Fereday. 2021. ‘Supporting the Performance of Noongar Language in Hecate.’ Theatre, Dance and Performance Training 12, no. 3: 377–95. https://doi.org/10.1080/19443927.2021.1943506
- Braun, Virginia, and Victoria Clarke. 2006. ‘Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.’ Qualitative Research in Psychology 3, no. 2: 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
- Burke, Kelly. 2022. ‘Australian Arts Sector Says Budget Cuts during Pandemic Recovery “Highly Disappointing”.’ Guardian Australia, 31 March 2022. https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2022/mar/31/australian-arts-sector-says-budget-cuts-during-pandemic-recovery-highly-disappointing
- Callinan, Tara. 2014. ‘Remote Indigenous Australians Rely on Facebook to Stay in Touch.’ SBS News, 26 August 2014. http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2014/08/26/remote-indigenous-australians-rely-facebook-stay-touch
- Carlson, Bronwyn, and Ryan Frazer. 2015. ‘“It’s Like Going to a Cemetery and Lighting a Candle”: Aboriginal Australians, Sorry Business and Social Media.’ AlterNative: An International Journal of Indigenous Peoples 11, no. 3: 211–24. https://doi.org/10.1177/117718011501100301
- Doubleday, Veronica. 2008. ‘Sounds of Power: An Overview of Musical Instruments and Gender.’ Ethnomusicology Forum 17, no. 1: 3–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/17411910801972909
- Dudgeon, Pat, Abigail Bray, Belinda D’Costa, and Roz Walker. 2017. ‘Decolonising Psychology: Validating Social and Emotional Wellbeing.’ Australian Psychologist 52, no. 4: 316–25. https://doi.org/10.1111/ap.12294
- Dudgeon, Pat, Kathleen Cox, D’Anna Divina, Cheryl Dunkley, Katherine Hams, Kerrie Kelly, Clair Scrine, and Roz Walker. 2012. ‘Hear Our Voices: Community Consultations for the Development of an Empowerment, Healing and Leadership Program for Aboriginal People Living in the Kimberley, Western Australia.’ Centre for Research Excellence, Aboriginal Health & Wellbeing, Telethon Institute for Child Health Research, University of Western Australia. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/232275608_Hear_our_voices_Community_consultations_for_the_development_of_an_empowerment_healing_and_leadership_program_for_Aboriginal_people_living_in_the_Kimberley_Western_Australia_-_Final_research_report
- Eltham, Ben. 2022. ‘No, the Federal Government Didn’t Spend $4 Billion on COVID Arts Support.’ Arts Hub, 23 February 2022. https://www.artshub.com.au/news/opinions-analysis/no-the-federal-government-didnt-spend-4-billion-on-covid-arts-support-2532401/
- Farnbach, Sara, Anne-Maree Eades, Josephine D. Gwynn, Nick Glozier, and Maree Hackett. 2018. ‘The Conduct of Australian Indigenous Primary Health Care Research Focusing on Social and Emotional Wellbeing: A Systematic Review.’ Public Health Research & Practice 28, no. 2: e27451704. https://doi.org/10.17061/phrp27451704
- Fisher, Daniel. 2013. ‘Intimacy and Self-Abstraction: Radio as New Media in Aboriginal Australia.’ Culture, Theory and Critique 54, no. 3: 372–93. https://doi.org/10.1080/14735784.2013.818278
- Flew, Terry, and Katherine Kirkwood. 2021. ‘The Impact of COVID-19 on Cultural Tourism: Art, Culture and Communication in Four Regional Sites of Queensland, Australia.’ Media International Australia 178, no. 1: 16–20. https://doi.org/10.1177/1329878X20952529
- Flore, Jacinthe, Natalie Ann Hendry, and Averyl Gaylor. 2023. ‘Creative Arts Workers during the Covid-19 Pandemic: Social Imaginaries in Lockdown.’ Journal of Sociology 59, no. 1: 197–214. https://doi.org/10.1177/14407833211036757
- Freeland, Anna, and Hannah Reich. 2022. ‘The Show Must Go On.’ ABC News, 5 April 2022. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-05/covid-impact-on-australian-theatre-and-performing-arts-funding/100868278
- Gee, Graham, Pat Dudgeon, Clinton Schultz, Amanda Hart, and Kerrie Kelly. 2014. ‘Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social and Emotional Wellbeing.’ In Working Together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Mental Health and Wellbeing Principles and Practice, edited by Pat Dudgeon, Helen Milroy, and Roz Walker, 2nd ed., 55–68. Barton, ACT: Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing. https://www.telethonkids.org.au/our-research/early-environment/developmental-origins-of-child-health/expired-projects/working-together-second-edition/
- Haebich, Anna. 2018. Dancing in Shadows: Histories of Nyungar Performance. Perth, WA: UWA Publishing.
- Hargittai, Eszter, and Kerry Dobransky. 2017. ‘Old Dogs, New Clicks: Digital Inequality in Skills and Uses among Older Adults.’ Canadian Journal of Communication 42, no. 2: 195–212. https://doi.org/10.22230/cjc.2017v42n2a3176
- Healy, Jessica de Largy. 2013. ‘Yolngu Zorba Meets Superman. Australian Aboriginal People, Mediated Publicness and the Culture of Sharing on the Internet.’ Anthrovision Vaneasa Online Journal 1, no. 1. https://doi.org/10.4000/anthrovision.362
- Hensel, Jennifer M., Katherine Ellard, Mark Koltek, Gabrielle Wilson, and Jitender Sareen. 2019. ‘Digital Health Solutions for Indigenous Mental Well-Being.’ Current Psychiatry Reports 21, no. 8: 68–9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11920-019-1056-6
- Kickett-Tucker, Cheryl S. 2009. ‘Moorn (Black)? Djardak (White)? How Come I Don’t Fit in Mum? Exploring the Racial Identity of Australian Aboriginal Children and Youth.’ Health Sociology Review 18, no. 1: 119–36. https://doi.org/10.5172/hesr.18.1.119
- Kickett-Tucker, Cheryl, and Josey Hansen. 2016. ‘Ngalang moort: Family as the Building Block of Community Development.’ In Mia Mia Aboriginal Community Development: Fostering Cultural Security, edited by Cheryl Kickett-Tucker, with Dawn Bessarab, Juli Coffin, and Michael Wright, 199–216. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107741768
- Lumby, Bronwyn. 2010. ‘Cyber-Indigeneity: Urban Indigenous Identity on Facebook.’ The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education 39, no. S1: 68–75. https://ajie.atsis.uq.edu.au/ajie/article/view/580/520. https://doi.org/10.1375/S1326011100001150
- McNeill, Heather. 2020. ‘A Timeline of WA’s COVID-19 Response: Was Our Success Luck, Good Management, or a Bit of Both?’ WA Today, 28 August 2020. https://www.watoday.com.au/national/western-australia/a-timeline-of-wa-s-covid-19-response-was-our-success-luck-good-management-or-a-bit-of-both-20200827-p55q03.html
- Morris, Linda. 2022. ‘Billions in Crisis Payments Paid to the Arts, New Report Shows.’ Sydney Morning Herald, 16 February 2022. https://www.smh.com.au/culture/art-and-design/billions-in-crisis-payments-paid-to-the-arts-new-report-shows-20220215-p59wpx.html
- National Congress of Australia’s First Peoples. 2011. Statement to the Australian Government on the Inquiry into Language Learning in Indigenous Communities. December 2011. https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Issues/IPeoples/EMRIP/StudyLanguages/NationalCongressAustralia2.pdf
- Nelson, Jacqueline, Heather MacDonald, Kevin Dunn, and Yin Paradies. 2016. ‘Ethnic Discrimination in Private Rental Housing Markets in Australia.’ In Housing in 21st-Century Australia, edited by Rae Dufty-Jones and Dallas Rogers, 53–70. London: Routledge.
- Newby, Jill M., Kathleen O’Moore, Samantha Tang, Helen Christensen, and Kate Faasse. 2020. ‘Acute Mental Health Responses during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Australia.’ PLoS One 15, no. 7: e0236562. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0236562
- Pennington, Alison, and Ben Eltham. 2021. Creativity in Crisis: Rebooting Australia’s Arts and Entertainment Sector after COVID. Canberra, ACT: The Centre for Future Work at the Australia Institute. https://australiainstitute.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Creativity_in_Crisis-_Rebooting_Australias_Arts___Entertainment_Sector_-_FINAL_-_26_July.pdf
- Perrin, Paul C., O. Lee McCabe, George S. Everly, and Jonathan M. Links. 2009. ‘Preparing for an Influenza Pandemic: Mental Health Considerations.’ Prehospital and Disaster Medicine 24, no. 3: 223–30. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1049023X00006853
- Pilat, Lauren, and Hamish Hastie. 2020. ‘McGowan Eases Gatherings Rules after Another Day of Zero Coronavirus Cases.’ WA Today, 26 April 2020. https://www.watoday.com.au/national/western-australia/mcgowan-eases-gatherings-rules-after-another-day-of-zero-coronavirus-cases-20200426-p54ncn.html
- Rennie, Ellie, Andrew Crouch, Julian Thomas, and Peter Taylor. 2010. ‘Beyond Public Access? Reconsidering Broadband for Remote Indigenous Communities.’ Communication, Politics & Culture 43, no. 1: 48–69. 10.3316/INFORMIT.147723177749030.
- Rose, Deborah Bird. 1996. Nourishing Terrains: Australian Aboriginal Views of Landscape and Wilderness. Canberra: Australian Heritage Commission.
- Schram, Ashley, Sharon Friel, Toby Freeman, Matthew Fisher, Fran Baum, and Patrick Harris. 2018. ‘Digital Infrastructure as a Determinant of Health Equity: An Australian Case Study of the Implementation of the National Broadband Network.’ Australian Journal of Public Administration 77, no. 4: 829–42. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8500.12323
- Shehadie, Alexandra, Sam Turner, Prabha Nandagopal, Bobbie Trower, and Grace Gardiner. 2022. Raising Their Voices: Report into Sexual Harm, Sexual Harassment and Systemic Discrimination in the Contemporary Music Industry. Support Act Ltd with MAPN Consulting. https://musicindustryreview.com.au
- Stuart, Jaimee, Karlee O’Donnell, Alex O’Donnell, Riley Scott, and Bonnie Barber. 2021. ‘Online Social Connection as a Buffer of Health Anxiety and Isolation during COVID-19.’ Cyberpsychology, Behavior and Social Networking 24, no. 8: 521–25. https://doi.org/10.1089/cyber.2020.0645
- Sunderland, Naomi, Phil Graham, Brydie-Leigh Bartleet, Darren Garvey, Clint Bracknell, Kristy Apps, Glenn Barry, Rae Cooper, Brigitta Scarfe, and Stacey Vervoort. 2023. ‘First Nations Music as a Determinant of Health in Australia and Vanuatu: Political and Economic Determinants.’ Health Promotion International 38, no. 2: daac190. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapro/daac190
- Terzon, Emilia. 2020. ‘Australia’s Arts and Entertainment Industry Thrown into Turmoil by Coronavirus Crowd Restrictions.’ ABC News, 15 March 2020. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-03-15/arts-entertainment-industry-thrown-into-turmoil-by-coronavirus/12057082
- Usher, Kim, Rhonda Marriott, Reakeeta Smallwood, Roz Walker, Carrington Shepherd, Katrina Hopkins, Petra Skeffington, Corianne Reid, and Debra Jackson. 2020. ‘COVID-19 and Social Restrictions: The Potential Mental Health Impact of Social Distancing and Isolation for Young Indigenous Australians.’ Australasian Psychiatry 28, no. 5: 599–600. https://doi.org/10.1177/1039856220943018
- Vaarzon-Morel, Petronella. 2014. ‘Pointing the Phone: Transforming Technologies and Social Relations among Warlpiri.’ The Australian Journal of Anthropology 25, no. 2: 239–55. https://doi.org/10.1111/taja.12091
- Walker, Roz, Kim Usher, Debra Jackson, Corinne Reid, Katrina Hopkins, Carrington Shepherd, Reakeeta Smallwood, Rhonda Marriott. 2021. ‘Connection to … Addressing Digital Inequities in Supporting the Well-Being of Young Indigenous Australians in the Wake of COVID-19.’ International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 18, no. 4: 2141. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18042141
- Walter, Maggie. 2008. ‘Lives of Diversity: Indigenous Australia.’ Occasional Paper 4, Census Series No. 2. Canberra: Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia. https://apo.org.au/node/3768