ABSTRACT
From its inception until now, Pentecostalism has thrived among Black communities, women and those experiencing socio-economic deprivation. Pentecostal theological ethicists have dealt in some ways with the themes of race, class and gender but often as single issues, meaning that Black women, who exist at the intersections, can be overlooked. Womanist ethics has a particular contribution to make to Pentecostal theology and Pentecostal studies since womanists centre the Spirit, as well as the lived experiences and faith of Black women in a world (and churches) marked indelibly by racism, sexism and classism. Given the centrality of the Bible in Black Pentecostal women’s spirituality, in this article, I examine the case of the Hellenistic widows in Acts 6 which illustrates the importance of Pentecostal womanism for critiquing the problems of race, gender and class, that shape even the Spirit-filled community not only in the early church but also today.
Introduction
Womanist theology emerged in the writings of Delores Williams, Katie Cannon and Jacquelyn Grant, those whom Monica Coleman refers to as ‘the first wave’.Footnote1 In the theological work of these scholars, God was discussed, as God appeared in the lives and experiences of Black women. The starting point was Black women’s experiences in a world distorted by racism, sexism and classism. It is in this context, that God made Godself known, as Black women talked with and about God, and worshipped God in the midst of their struggles and their joys. The biblical text is read in this tradition, through Black women’s experiences and with Black women’s questions and insights leading the dialogue. In this way, interpretation of the biblical text resists the harmful inscription of white (including white feminist), patriarchal and elitist hermeneutical norms. God is, in the womanist theology of this first generation, the one who sees the abused, mistreated and dehumanized Hagar, embodied in contemporary terms, in the African American enslaved woman and her descendant daughters.Footnote2 God is embodied as ‘Black women’s Jesus’: one who is familiar with the oppression Black women experience, under imperialistic violent structures himself.Footnote3 Black women may draw on theological resources such as the ‘imago dei, love as grounded in justice and the irreplaceable nature of community’ to sustain and nurture life in the context of struggle in public life, and also in the church.Footnote4
The foundation laid by these scholars has since been built upon by subsequent generations of womanists who have also broadened the scope of womanist work. Womanist theology and biblical studies now include as varied subjects as there are Black women to think of them. Yet there are certain commitments which remain at the core for all. Wilda Gafney, a womanist biblical scholar explains womanist hermeneutical approaches as:
1) … being regularly multidimensional; they can be interdisciplinary, collaborative and/or multicontextual. 2) They emphasise and prioritise women’s experience in general and the social location of the reader/interpreter in particular. 3) A (if not the) goal of womanist discourse is the eradication of all forms of human oppression. 4) The fruit of womanist scholarship must be accessible to the wider non-specialist worshipping community.Footnote5
In the first part of this article, I begin by exploring the interrelatedness between womanism and Pentecostalism, particularly in the thought of Yolanda Pierce and then in the UK context. I follow this by providing a theological case for the importance of womanist Pentecostal work, by examining the treatment of the Hellenistic widows in Acts 6. This passage of scripture offers a motif for examining the place of Black women in the community of the Spirit-filled and the ongoing need for ‘womanist ways’.Footnote9
Pentecostal and womanist
Pentecostalism from the outset has emerged and grown due to the faith and faithfulness of Black women. It is a faith that is built upon the experience of God, the Spirit in particular among ‘those with their backs against the wall’.Footnote10 Black working women of the early 1900s were not only present but also leaders among the early communities from which the Azusa Street revival would emerge.Footnote11 Pentecostalism can be understood in part as a womanist movement, in terms of the role of Black women in its emergence. For Keri Day who emphasizes the ‘Black Female Genius’ which underpinned the Azusa Street revival,Footnote12 it is the voices, labour and leadership of Black women which made the revival what it was. This is not simply in terms of their position in embracing the ministry of the Holy Spirit in and through their lives, but the prophetic witness of their spirituality and ministry which resisted the capitalistic white supremacist norms of their wider social and political context.Footnote13 This is true despite the attempts by men of all races to restrain Black women and prevent them from living and expressing themselves as people freed by the Spirit in whom they had been baptized.Footnote14
Yolanda Pierce has provided us with a clear framework for how we might approach Pentecostalism through a womanist lens. The question of whether Pentecostalism and womanism are compatible is superfluous for Pierce, who explains that ‘these two identities have been linked together since the origins of the faith’.Footnote15 For Pierce, the relevant question is ‘When did Pentecostalism stop affirming a … womanist identity?’.Footnote16 In her essay ‘Womanist Ways and Pentecostalism: The Work of Recovery and Critique’ she outlines four ways to reverse this trend and bring the two into dialogue:
A womanist approach to the study of early Pentecostalism critiques the mythic egalitarian origins of Pentecostal identity … examines the various outcomes, especially for women, for a ‘movement’ that transitioned to an ‘institution’ … considers both the blessings and the costs of daring to claim a womanist identity … [and] is unafraid to examine other theological models for revelation of truth.Footnote17
Though Pierce is focused here on the need to articulate a womanist approach to Pentecostal studies, what she offers is a tool for womanist Pentecostal approaches to reading scripture and undertaking the theological task. For Black Pentecostals and Black Pentecostal women especially, the bible has consistently functioned as an essential source for encounters with the divine and reflection on their lived experience.Footnote19 In the words of Renita Weems:
The bible (rather, its contents) has not been presented to African American women as one of a number of books available to her to read as she pleases. For African American (Protestant) women, the bible has been the only book passed down from her ancestors, and it has been presented to her as the medium for experiencing and knowing the will of the Christian God.Footnote20
In Pierce’s summary of womanist ways and Pentecostalism, we are invited to welcome new approaches to studies of the Pentecostal movement. Yet, what she describes also opens up new ways of considering all that contributes to Pentecostal identity, including the reading of core Pentecostal texts. If ‘womanist ways’, require us to critique the ‘mythic egalitarian origins’ of the Pentecostal movement, how might this apply to how Pentecostals can idealize the stories of the Spirit-baptized community in the book of Acts? If womanism requires us to examine outcomes for Black women, then surely this must also require us to look at how notions of gender as well as ethnicity (if not race) or economic status (if not class) shape the lives of those considered to offer a framework for how Pentecostals should be and think? How might the ‘blessings and costs’ of womanism appear as this biblical and theological work is undertaken? And what other resources might enhance a re-reading of the Spirit-baptized community of Acts, in the light of these womanist commitments?
In the UK, Maxine Howell has sought to address the questions of Black women’s approaches to scripture in the construction of their identity. Through what she calls a Womanist Pneumatological Pedagogy (WPP) Black women gather together to reread biblical texts in light of their lived experiences. This re-reading is necessary because:
Firstly, the content of traditional readings of the Bible conceal rather than reveal the vitality of women. Black people and the poor in the fulfilment of the gospel. Secondly, the research methods used in readings, even unconventional ones, can be rooted in positivist approaches that reflect the Eurocentric masculinist epistemology, which dominates our institutions and social processes.Footnote24
The centring of Black women’s experience, historical memory, hermeneutic of suspicion, multi-dimensional analysis and the pursuit of socio-political wholeness {which the British Black sojourners employ). These tools … allow Black women to challenge unjust forms of church action and thought in order to facilitate social change in a variety of ways.Footnote27
The Hellenistic widows: A case for Pentecostal womanism
Recognizing the symbiotic relationship between womanist ethics and Pentecostalism is not only significant for a deeper understanding of the sociology and history of the Pentecostal movement. Reading biblical texts with a womanist lens enables us to uncover often overlooked perspectives. To read with a womanist lens is to centre the women in the biblical text who are often unnamed, or unseen. It is to look behind and around the dominating male figures who the biblical writers have often chosen to focus on, and instead to look for the everyday women who are considered less important or inconsequential. Clarice J. Martin explains,
The quest for holistic and inclusive translations and interpretations must also include strategies for ‘amplifying the whisper’ of all persons who by virtue of race, class or other anthropological referents, are assumed to be ‘morally bankrupt’ or of negligible theological consequence within the narrative structure of biblical traditions.Footnote28
The Acts of the Apostles offer a foundation for Pentecostal theology and ethics primarily through the story of Pentecost and the ensuing transformation of the early church. Passages from the book of Acts have formed the basis for charismatic theologies, encouraging believers to anticipate and seek their own baptism in the Holy Spirit, with the evidence of speaking in tongues. Similarly, expectations of physical healing, deliverance from demons and other supernatural occurrences also find their main impetus in this book. The pattern of the early church’s life described in Acts 2:42–47 has developed into an idealized vision of this first-century gathering of believers. The text reads that ‘they devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and to fellowship, to the breaking of bread and to prayer’. Luke’s words that ‘all the believers were together and had everything in common’ and sold ‘property and possessions to give to anyone who had need’ offers a challenge to contemporary forms of Christianity impacted by and sometimes deeply intertwined with individualism and consumerism.
Nevertheless, bearing in mind Pierce’s warning regarding the temptation of uncritically accepting ‘mythic egalitarian origins’,Footnote29 we must examine the moments in Acts, where we detect that there is more to this vision of a perfect church. While it may seem on the surface at least that the values and practices of this new community, were completely aligned with the Gospel of the risen Jesus, we also detect signs that all was not well in this regard. In Acts 5:1–11 we read the story of Ananias and Sapphira which is often interpreted as a story of God’s judgment against those who deceive. Yet it is also possible for this story to speak of the forms of social pressure that may have been generated by the ideals of the Early Church. Why did Ananias believe he had to lie about giving all of his money to the Apostles? Was he afraid of being judged? Was there a subtle indication that nothing less than total generosity to the cause would be expected, despite Peter’s words: ‘Didn’t it belong to you before it was sold? And after it was sold, wasn’t the money at your disposal?’ (Acts 5:4, NIV). Why did Sapphira suffer the same fate? Wasn’t supporting her husband’s lies, what was expected?Footnote30 All is not well in the life of the early church. This unfortunate incident is followed in Chapter 6, by a brief reference to a problem that was occurring with food distribution:
In those days when the number of disciples was increasing, the Hellenistic Jews among them complained against the Hebraic Jews because their widows were being overlooked in the daily distribution of food. (Acts 6:1, NIV)
There are various perspectives on the socio-economic and political status of the widows in the story, which are important for us to bear in mind as we seek to explore this passage with attentiveness to the lives and experiences of Black women and all those whose lives are marked by race, gender and class. We might assume, based in part on the biblical narratives surrounding widows, that the women in Acts 6 are socio-economically vulnerable, but this should not be taken for granted. It is clear in Jewish tradition that widows were generally considered to be in a precarious position. This was especially the case for childless widows or those without the option of marrying a brother of their late husband to continue his line.Footnote34 Therefore, provision is made within the Levitical law to ensure that widows are looked after and cared for along with the ‘orphan’ and the ‘stranger’.Footnote35 In the Gospels, we come across scriptural passages which can reinforce the image of the poor and victimized widow, such as the story of the widow’s offering in Mark 12:41–44 and Luke 1:21–24. And yet we also find stories of widows demonstrating a strong sense of personal agency despite their difficult circumstances. Keenan has argued for example that
Ancient readers would know that women, especially widows, could safely get away with complaining and even harassing authorities in ways that men could not; such demands were often their only means for securing redress against injustices. The widows here may continue in the path of earlier biblical widows who heroically and unconventionally sought their rights.Footnote36
Race was of course not a reality of ancient life, as it is today. However, the divisions of identity and belonging which shaped the multicultural world of the early church were prevalent and are important for us to consider. Mitzi Smith has argued, for example, that ‘Hebrew widows were performing the daily diakonia for all widows but their service to the Hellenistic widows was less than through’.Footnote39 This is an example of the problems of equity, belonging and justice that Love Lazarus Sechrest argues marked the early church in Acts as they do communities today:
Luke describes the ideal family: it is a diverse family, encompassing members from all corners of the cosmos, and an intercultural one, supernaturally equipped to break boundaries of geography and culture (Acts 2:1–11) … Composed of Greek and Aramaic-speaking Jews and God-fearing Gentiles, it is a cross-cultural family that must learn to bridge differences and respect boundaries.Footnote40
Diaspora people are always on edge, because they know the stakes. They understand that life together as a people is not a given. It must be won again and again against those alien forces that would undermine it, drain it of life, and leave it sickly and dying. Those who came to Jerusalem were diaspora, of different tongues and cultural knowledge(s) but of same commitment against the threats to Israel’s life.Footnote42
It is telling, that the Apostles have somehow imagined that discrimination against certain widows is not something they should be concerned with. The care of widows was paramount to their Jewish heritage and to the ministry of Jesus as recorded by Luke. Yet the Apostles seem to succumb to a hierarchy of ministry in which the plight of the Hellenistic widows is treated as a distraction. This may be due to the busyness of their lives leading a growing community. But it is lamentable that they so quickly imagine that there are some issues, that are core to their role, while others are somewhat below them. Prayer and preaching are important tasks for these Apostles, but ensuring justice in the community of faith can, in their view, be delegated. They are exposed by Luke, as failing to blend the ‘two vocations of preaching and teaching, with service at the table’ which Jesus embodied.Footnote50
The case of the Hellenistic widows exemplifies the reality of life for Black women, and all who experience ‘othering’Footnote51 in church life, political life and even in the biblical text. Evidence of these forms of racial, gender and class inequity has been presented and clarified by Black feminist/womanist scholars over several decades. But in Acts, we find a particular account of how these issues of identity, belonging, privilege and power, can shape the life of the community of those who are filled with the Holy Spirit. While Black women may exhibit a ‘pained resilience’ in light of their social, political and economic positioning, in Keri Day’s words, this can continue rather than being relieved in the congregation of the ‘sanctified’.Footnote52 Both the story of the Hellenistic widows and Day’s womanist reading of Azusa Street, remind us of the ways minoritized women living in the diaspora can find themselves neglected, overlooked and restricted in communities in which they expect to find home and belonging. Both call us to attend to the myriad of ways men of all ethnicities, when in positions of leadership, can often neglect the particularities of women’s experiences and subsequently fail to respond to them adequately.
Conclusion
This text speaks to the reason why ‘womanist ways’, as Pierce describes, must permeate Pentecostal thought and practice. This goes beyond simply recognizing the role Black women have played in Pentecostal movements, or starting with the Black woman’s encounter with God. If Pentecostalism is going to rediscover its prophetic identity it must be committed to the womanist call, which demands it urgently attend to the matters of power which marginalize and exclude within the very doors of the church, as well as beyond. For Black Pentecostal Women, this requires a womanist approach to biblical texts which are central to Pentecostal identity. Attending to the overlooked figures, reflecting on the ways gender, ethnicity or race and class impact upon their lives is central to the womanist biblical project. In this way, Pentecostals, who are people of the Word and the Spirit, might develop a more holistic understanding of what it means to be those who continue to live in the life made possible at Pentecost.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).
Additional information
Notes on contributors
Selina Stone
Dr Selina Stone is a Postdoctoral Research Associate in Theological Education with Common Awards.
Notes
1 Coleman, Ain’t I a Womanist, Too?, 42.
2 Williams, Sisters in the Wilderness, 23
3 Grant, White Women’s Christ and Black Women’s Jesus, 6.
4 Cannon, Black Womanist Ethics, 160.
5 Gafney, “A Black Feminist Approach to Biblical Studies,” 392.
6 Smith, “This Little Light of Mine,” 112–18.
7 Alice Walker was the first to use the term ‘womanist’ in In Search of Our Mothers Gardens, xi–xii.
8 Harris, Gifts of Virtue, Alice Walker, 125–38; and Coleman, Ain’t I a Womanist, Too?, 43.
9 Pierce, “Womanist Ways,” 24–34.
10 Thurman, Jesus and the Disinherited, 1.
11 Alexander, The Women of Azusa Street, Revised ed., 15–21; 22–36; 39–51; 96–105; 193–204.
12 Day, Azusa Reimagined, 74.
13 Ibid., 74–103.
14 Ibid., 53–4, 88–90, 96.
15 Pierce, “Womanist Ways,” 26.
16 Emphasis mine, ibid., 26–7.
17 Ibid., 30–4.
18 Gafney, “A Black Feminist Approach to Biblical Studies,” 392.
19 Harris, “Black Pentecostal Hermeneutics?” 213–14, 216–17; Butler, Women in the Church of God in Christ, 17–26; and Gilkes, “You’ve Got a Right to the Tree of Life,” 154–5, 164–7.
20 Weems, “Reading Her Way Through the Struggle,” 63.
21 Gilkes, “You’ve Got a Right to the Tree of Life,” 153–4, 159, 161–2; Butler, “Only a Woman Would Do,” 155–78; Toulis, Believing Identity, 139–41; and Weems, “Reading Her Way Through the Struggle,” 60–72.
22 Day, Azusa Reimagined, 4–5, 68–9; and Toulis, Believing Identity, 125. This is not only true for Pentecostals but often for Christians more generally, see Johnson, Prophetic Jesus and Prophetic Church, 4, 96–129.
23 Williams, “Acts,” 213–48.
24 Howell, “Towards a Womanist Pneumatological Pedagogy,” 87.
25 Harris, “Black Pentecostal Hermeneutics?” 202–17.
26 Wimberly, Soul Stories, 39.
27 Howell, “Towards a Womanist Pneumatological Pedagogy,” 92.
28 Martin, “Womanist Interpretations of the New Testament,” 55.
29 Pierce, “Womanist Ways,” 30.
30 For a womanist reading of this story see Smith, The Literary Construction, 102–13.
31 Schüssler Fiorenza, In Memory of Her, 162; Spencer, “Neglected Widows,” 728; and Smith, The Literary Construction, 114. See also Martin Hengel who argues that the influence of Hellenistic culture on Jewish Palestinian life can be traced back to 260–250 BC meaning that ‘from about the middle of the third century BC all Judaism must really be designated as “Hellenistic Judaism” in the strict sense, and a better differentiation could be made between the Greek-speaking Judaism of the Western Diaspora and the Aramaic/Hebrew-speaking Judaism of Palestine and Babylonia’. Hengel, Judaism and Hellenism, 103–4.
32 Keener, Acts, 221.
33 Schüssler Fiorenza, In Memory of Her, 162, 166.
34 Galpaz-Feller, “The Widow in the Bible,” 234–7.
35 Ibid., 232–3, 234, 238.
36 Keener, Acts, 222.
37 Spencer, “Neglected Widows,” 728.
38 Ibid., 729.
39 Smith, The Literary Construction, 118.
40 Sechrest, Race and Rhyme, 152.
41 Hengel, Judaism and Hellenism, 6–103.
42 Jennings, Acts, 59.
43 Schüssler Fiorenza, In Memory of Her, 161; and Spencer, “Neglected Widows,” 716.
44 Keena, Acts, 225.
45 Reid, “The Power of the Widows,” 73.
46 Seim, The Double Message, 122–123
47 Spencer, “Neglected Widows,” 729.
48 Smith, The Literary Construction, 114, 118–19.
49 Reid, “The Power of the Widows,” 85.
50 Spencer, “Neglected Widows,” 729–30. For a discussion of contrasting views see Smith, The Literary Construction, 116–17.
51 Smith, The Literary Construction, 1–10.
52 Day, Azusa Reimagined, 75–83, 88–9.
Bibliography
- Alexander, Estrelda Y. The Women of Azusa Street. Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim Press, 2005. Revised ed. Lanham, MD: Seymour Press, 2023.
- Butler, Anthea. “‘Only a Woman Would Do’: Bible Reading and African American Women’s Organizing Work.” In Women and Religion in the African Diaspora: Knowledge, Power, and Performance, edited by R. Marie Griffith, 155–178. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006.
- Butler, Anthea. Women in the Church of God in Christ: Making a Sanctified World. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2012.
- Cannon, Katie. Black Womanist Ethics. Atlanta, GA: Scholars Press, 1988.
- Coleman, Monica A., ed. Ain’t I a Womanist, Too? Third Wave Womanist Religious Thought. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 2013.
- Day, Keri. Azusa Reimagined: A Radical Vision of Religious and Democratic Belonging. Redwood City, CA: Stanford University Press, 2022.
- Gafney, Wilda C. “A Black Feminist Approach to Biblical Studies.” Encounter 67, no. 4 (Autumn, 2006): 391–403.
- Galpaz-Feller, Pnina. “The Widow in the Bible and in Ancient Egypt.” Zeitschrift Für Die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 120, no. 2 (2008): 231–253.
- Gilkes, Cheryl Townsend. “‘You’ve Got a Right to the Tree of Life’: The Biblical Foundations of an Empowered Attitude among Black Women in the Sanctified Church.” In Philip’s Daughters: Women in Pentecostal-Charismatic Leadership, edited by Estrelda Alexander and Amos Yong, 152–169. Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 2009.
- Grant, Jacquelyn. White Women’s Christ and Black Women’s Jesus: Feminist Christology and Womanist response. Atlanta, GA: Scholars Press, 1989.
- Harris, M. Gifts of Virtue, Alice Walker, and Womanist Ethics. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010.
- Harris, Antipas L. “Black Pentecostal Hermeneutics?: James H. Cone’s Theological Sources and Black Pentecostalism.” Pneuma 41, no. 2 (2019): 193–217. https://doi-org.ezphost.dur.ac.uk/10.1163/15700747-04102004.
- Howell, Maxine. “Towards a Womanist Pneumatological Pedagogy: Reading and Re-Reading the Bible from British Black Women’s Perspectives.” Black Theology 7, no. 1 (April 2009): 86–99.
- Jennings, Willie James. Acts: A Theological Commentary on the Bible. Louisville, KY: Presbyterian, 2017.
- Keener, Craig. Acts. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020.
- Martin, Clarice J. “Womanist Interpretations of the New Testament: The Quest for Holistic and Inclusive Translation and Interpretation.” Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion 6, no. 2 (Fall 1990): 41–61.
- Pierce, Yolanda. “Womanist Ways and Pentecostalism: The Work of Recovery and Critique.” Pneuma 35, no. 1 (2013): 24–34.
- Reid, Barbara. “The Power of the Widows and How to Suppress It (Acts 6:1–7).” In A Feminist Companion to the Acts of the Apostles, edited by Amy-Jill Levine, 71–88. Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim Press, 2004.
- Schüssler Fiorenza, Elisabeth. In Memory of Her: A Feminist Theological Reconstruction of Christian Origins. London: SCM, 1983.
- Sechrest, Love Lazarus. Race and Rhyme: Rereading the New Testament. Chicago, IL: Eerdmans, 2022.
- Seim, Turid Karlesen. The Double Message: Patterns of Gender in Luke-Acts. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1994.
- Smith, Mitzi J. The Literary Construction of the Other in the Acts of the Apostles: Charismatics, the Jews, and Women. Eugene, OR: Pickwick, 2011.
- Smith, Mitzi J. “‘This Little Light of Mine’: The Womanist Biblical Scholar as Prophetess, Iconoclast and Activist.” In I Found God in Me: A Womanist Biblical Hermeneutics Reader, edited by Mitzi J. Smith, 109–127. Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2015.
- Spencer, F. Scott. “Neglected Widows in Acts 6:1–7.” Catholic Biblical Quarterly 56 (1994): 714–733.
- Thurman, Howard. Jesus and the Disinherited. Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 1976.
- Toulis, Nicole. Believing Identity: Pentecostalism and the Mediation of Jamaican Ethnicity and Gender in England. London: Taylor & Francis, 1997.
- Walker, Alice. In Search of Our Mothers’ Gardens: Womanist Prose. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1983.
- Weems, Renita J. “Reading Her Way Through the Struggle: African American Women and the Bible.” In Stony the Road We Trod: African American Biblical Interpretation, edited by Cain Hope Felder, 57–77. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1991.
- Williams, Delores. Sisters in the Wilderness: The Challenge of Womanist God-Talk. New York, NY: Orbis Books, 1993.
- Williams, Demetrius K. “Acts.” In True to Our Native Land: An African American New Testament Commentary, edited by Brian K. Blount, Cain Hope Felder, Clarice J. Martin, and Emerson B. Powery, 213–248. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 2007.
- Wimberly, Anne Streaty. Soul Stories: African American Christian Education. Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press, 1994.