Advanced search
Publication Cover
Conflict, Security & Development Volume 23, 2023 - Issue 6
Submit an article Journal homepage
705
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research Article

Whose security? Whose justice? Customary authorities in security and justice interventions in the Horn of Africa

Paul Jacksona African Politics, The University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UKCorrespondence[email protected]
ORCID Iconhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-0933-028XView further author information
ORCID Icon &
Veronica Stratford-Tukeb International Centtre of Expertise on Illicit Finance, Foreign Commonwealth & Development Office, London, UKView further author information
Pages 611-633 | Published online: 27 Nov 2023

References

  • Abdi Omer, M. and A. M. Jibril, 2017. Hybrid Security Governance in Somaliland. International Development Research Centre, Ottowa.
  • Acemoglu, D. and J. A. Robinson, 2012. Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity and Poverty. Profile Books, London.
  • Albrecht, P. and L. Buur. 2009. ‘An Uneasy Marriage: Non-State Actors and Police Reform’. Policing and Society 19(4), 390–405.
  • Albrecht, P. and P. Jackson, 2009. Security Sector Transformation in Sierra Leone, 1997–2007. Global Facilitation Network for Security Sector Reform, Birmingham.
  • Albrecht, P. and H. M. Kyed, 2011. ‘Introduction’. In Perspectives on Involving Non-State and Customary Actors in Justice and Security Reform, eds. P. Albrecht, H. M. Kyed, D. Isser and E. Harper. Danish Institute for International Studies and the International Development Law Organization, Copenhagen, 54–60.
  • All Africa Global Media, 2013. Somali Leaders Pledge Judicial Reform Following Landmark Meeting. SyndiGate Media Inc, Washington, DC.
  • All Africa Global Media, 2014. Somalis Lament Lack of Progress on Judicial Reform. SyndiGate Media Inc, Washinton, DC.
  • Andemariam, S. W., 2011. Traditional Justice: Practitioners’ Perspectives: Working Paper. Ensuring Access to Justice Through Community Courts in Eritrea. International Development Law Organization, Rome.
  • Andersen, L. R., 2011. Security Sector Reform and the Dilemmas of Liberal Peacebuilding. DIIS Working Paper. Danish Institute for International Studies, Copenhagen.
  • Andersen, L. R., 2012. ‘The Liberal Dilemmas of a People-Centred Approach to State-Building’. Conflict, Security & Development 12(2), 103–121.
  • Andrews, M., L. Pritchett and M. Woolcock, 2013. ‘Escaping Capability Traps Through Problem Driven Iterative Adaptation (PDIA)’. World Development 51, 234–244.
  • Aning, K. and I. Axelrod, 2023. ‘Hybrid Security Provision in African Post-Colonial Settings: The Cases of Burkina Faso and Sierra Leone’. The International Spectator 58(2), 140–157.
  • Azadi, H., S. Burkart, S. S. Moghaddam, H. Mahmoudi, K. Janečková, P. Sklenička, P. Ho, D. Teklemariam and H. Nadiri, 2021. ‘Famine in the Horn of Africa: Understanding Institutional Arrangements in Land Tenure Systems’. Food Reviews International 17(sup1), 1525–6103.
  • Baker, B., 2013a. ‘Hybridity in Policing: The Case of Ethiopia’. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 45(3), 296–313.
  • Baker, B., 2013b. ‘Where Formal and Informal Justice Meet: Ethiopia’s Justice Pluralism’. African Journal of International and Cooperative Law 21(2), 202–218.
  • Bakrania, S., 2020a. Methodological Briefs on Evidence Synthesis Brief 2: Introduction. UNICEF, New York.
  • Bakrania, S., 2020b. Methodological Briefs on Evidence Synthesis Brief 3: Developing and Designing an Evidence Synthesis Product. UNICEF, New York.
  • Bakrania, S., 2020c. Methodological Briefs on Evidence Synthesis Brief 4: Collating and Analysing Studies for Synthesis. UNICEF, New York.
  • Belay, Y. D., 2014. ‘Community Policing or Policing the Community? The Emerging Police Practice in Ethiopia’. International Journal of Science and Research 3(9), 1948–1954.
  • Bell, J., P. Jackson and S. Bakrania, 2019. ‘Security and Justice Evidence Mapping Update’. GSDRC. Available at: https://gsdrc.org/publications/security-and-justice-evidence-mapping-update/
  • Bennett, W., 2014. Community Security Handbook. Saferworld, London.
  • Bereketeab, R., 2020. ‘State Legitimacy and Government Performance in the Horn of Africa’. African Studies 79(1), 51–69.
  • Berhane, Y., 2014. Mezard, Indigenous Conflict Resolution Mechanism in Northern Ethiopia. Anchor Academic Publishing, Hamburg.
  • Beyene, F., 2020. ‘The Security Sector Reform Paradox in Somalia’. Conflict Research Programme: London School of Economics.
  • Bierschenk, T., 2017. ‘Who are the Police in Africa?’ In Police in Africa: The Street Level View, eds. J. Beek, M. Göpfert, O. Owen and J. Steinberg. C. Hurst and Co, London, 103–120.
  • Booth, D., 2015. Thinking and Working Politically: GSDRC Professional Development Reading Pack Number 13. University of Birmingham, Birmingham.
  • Booth, D. and S. Unsworth, 2014. ‘Politically Smart, Locally Led Development (Discussion Paper)’. Overseas Development Institute, London.
  • Brinkerhoff, D. W., 2008. ‘The State and International Development Management: Shifting Tides, Changing Boundaries, and Future Directions’. Public Administration Review 68(6), 985–1001.
  • Brzoska, M., 2006. ‘Introduction: Criteria for Evaluating Post-Conflict Reconstruction and Security Sector Reform in Peace Support Operations’. International Peacekeeping 13(1), 1–13.
  • Burke, R., 2020. ‘Somalia and Legal Pluralism: Advancing Gender Justice Through Rule of Law Programming in Times of Transition’. Loyola University Chicago International Law Review 16(2), 177–213.
  • Cheeseman, N., 2015. Democracy in Africa: Successes, Failures and the Struggle for Political Reform. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
  • Danish Demining Group, 2016. Ddg’s Civic Engagement Project Heralds New Hope in State Building in Southern Somalia. Danish Demining Group, Copenhagen. https://danishdemininggroup.dk/news/ddg-s-civic-engagement-project-heralds-a-new-hope-in-state-building-in-southern-somalia
  • Dasandi, N., H. Marquette and M. Robinson, 2016. Thinking and Working Politically: From Theory Building to Building an Evidence Base. The University of Birmingham, Birmingham.
  • De Waal, A., 2020. ‘Somalia’s Disassembled State: Clan Unit Formation and the Political Marketplace’. Conflict, Security & Development 20(5), 561–585.
  • Denney, L., 2013. ‘Liberal Chiefs or Illiberal Development? The Challenge of Engaging Chiefs in Dfid’s Security Sector Reform Programme in Sierra Leone’. Development Policy Review 31(1), 5–25.
  • Denney, L. and D. Kassaye, 2013. Securing Communities for Development. Community Policing in Ethiopia’s Amhara National Regional State. ODI, London.
  • Denney, L. and C. Valters, 2015. Evidence Synthesis: Security Sector Reform and Organisational Capacity Building. Department for International Development, London.
  • Department for International Development, 2002. Safety, Security and Accessible Justice: Putting Policy into Practice. Department for International Development, London.
  • Department for International Development, 2007. Explanatory Note of Security and Access to Justice for the Poor. Department for International Development, London.
  • Department for International Development, 2014. How to Note: Assessing the Strength of Evidence. Department for International Development, London.
  • Department for International Development, 2019. Governance for Growth, Stability and Inclusive Development. Department for International Development, London.
  • Development Leadership Program, 2014. The Case for Thinking and Working Politically. University of Birmingham, Birmingham.
  • Dijkema, C., K. Gatelier, J. Tercinet and I. Samson, 2012. Rethinking the Foundations of the State: An Analysis of Post-Crisis Situations. Bruylant, Brussels.
  • Donais, T., 2009. ‘Inclusion or Exclusion? Local Ownership and Security Sector Reform’. Studies in Social Justice 3(1), 117–131.
  • EAJ, 2020. Access to Justice Assessment Tool: Somaliland Baseline Study. Expanding Access to Justice Program, Nairobi.
  • Enfield, S., 2019. Lessons of Working with Informal Security Actors. Institute of Development Studies, Brighton.
  • Enns, C., N. Andrews and A. Grant, 2020. ‘Security for Whom? Analysing Hybrid Security Governance in Africa’s Extractive Sectors’. International Affairs 96(4), 995–1013.
  • Evans, P., 2004. ‘Development as Institutional Change: The Pitfalls of Monocropping and the Potentials of Deliberation’. Studies in Comparative International Development 38(4), 30–52.
  • Fukuyama, F., 2011. The Origins of Political Order: From Prehuman Times to the French Revolution. Profile Books, London.
  • Fukuyama, F., 2014. Political Order and Political Decay: From the Industrial Revolution to the Globalisation of Democracy. Profile Books, London.
  • Global Facilitation Network for Security Sector Reform, 2007. A Beginner’s Guide to Security Sector Reform (SSR). Global Facilitation Network for Security Sector Reform, Birmingham.
  • Gordon, E. 2014. ‘Security Sector Reform, Local Ownership and Community Engagement’. International Journal of Security and Development 3(1), 1–18.
  • Gough, D., S. Oliver and J. Thomas, 2012. An Introduction to Systematic Reviews. Sage, London.
  • Green, D., 2016. How Change Happens. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  • Grindle, M., 2004. ‘Good Enough Governance: Poverty Reduction and Reform in Developing Countries’. Governance 17(4), 525–549.
  • Gundel, J., 2020a. Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in Somalia. Expanding Access to Justice Program, American Bar Association and Pact Kenya, Nairobi.
  • Gundel, J., 2020b. Pathways and Institutions for Resolving Land Disputes in Mogadishu. Expanding Access to Justice Program, American Bar Association and Pact Kenya, Nairobi.
  • Halloran, B., 2014. ‘Thinking and Working Politically in the Transparency and Accountability Field Transparency Accountability Initiative’.
  • Hammond, L., 2013. Safety, Security and Socio-Economic Wellbeing in Somaliland. SOAS, London.
  • Harborne, B., 2010. Security and Justice Overview: Security and Justice Thematic Paper. The World Bank, Washington, DC.
  • Harper, E., 2011. ‘Traditional Justice: Practitioners’ Perspectives’’. Working Paper Series. International Development Law Organization, Rome.
  • Harper, E., 2020. Gender Equality and Social Inclusion Analysis. Expanding Access to Justice Program. American Bar Association and Pact Kenya, Washington DC.
  • Higgins, J. P. T., J. Thomas, J. Chandler, M. Cumpston, T. Li, M. J. Page and V. A. Welch, 2021. ‘Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 6.2 (Updated February 2021)’. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester. Available at: www.training.cochrane.org/handbook
  • Hills, A., 2014. ‘Security Sector or Security Arena? The Evidence from Somalia’. International Peacekeeping 21(2), 165–180.
  • Homel, P. and N. Masson, 2016. ‘Partnerships for Human Security in Fragile Contexts: Where Community Safety and Security Sector Reform Intersect’. Australian Journal of International Affairs 70(3), 311–327.
  • Hudson, D., C. McLoughlin, H. Marquette and C. Roche, 2018. Inside the Black Box of Political Will: 10 Years of Findings from the Developmental Leadership Program. Development Leadership Program, Birmingham.
  • Independent Commission on Aid Impact, 2015. Review of UK Development Assistance for Security and Justice. Independent Commission on Aid Impact, London.
  • Institute of Development Studies, 2010. An Upside Down View of Governance. Institute of Development Studies, Brighton.
  • International Security Sector Advisory Team, 2017. ISSAT Background Note on Security Sector Reform in Somalia. International Security Sector Advisory Team, Geneva.
  • Jackson, P., 2011a. ‘Decentralised Authorities, Decentralised Power and Who Gets Access to Justice in Sierra Leone’. Journal of Legal Pluralism 63(63), 207–231.
  • Jackson, P., 2011b. ‘Security Sector Reform and State Building’. Third World Quarterly 32(10), 1803–1822.
  • Jackson, P. and S. Bakrania, 2018. ‘Is the Future of SSR Non-Linear?’ Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12(1), 11–30.
  • Jackson, P. and S. Bakrania, 2019. S&J Mapping Update. GSDRC, Birmingham.
  • Jackson, P. and D. Beswick, 2018. Conflict, Security and Development. Routledge, London.
  • Jackson, P., D. Kassaye and E. Shearon, 2018. ‘I Fought the Law and the Law Won: Evidence on Policing Communities in Dire Dawa, Ethiopia’. British Journal of Criminology 59(1), 126–143.
  • Law, D., 2006. The Post-Conflict Security Sector. Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces, Geneva.
  • Laws, E. and H. Marquette, 2018. Thinking and Working Politically: Reviewing the Evidence on the Integration of Politics into Development Practice Over the Past Decade. Thinking and Working Politically Community of Practice, London.
  • Laws, E., J. Pett, E. Proud and A. Rocha Menocal, 2021. LearnAdapt: A Synthesis of Our Work on Adaptive Programming with DFID/FCDO 2017–2020. Overseas Development Institute, London.
  • Lederach, J.-P., 1997. Building Peace: Sustainable Reconciliation in Divided Societies. United States Institute for Peace, Washington, DC.
  • Leftwich, A., 1994. ‘Governance, the State and the Politics of Development’. Development and Change 25(2), 363–386.
  • Leftwich, A., 2005. ‘Politics in Command: Development Studies and the Rediscovery of Social Science’. New Political Economy 10(4), 573–607.
  • Leftwich, A., 2011. Thinking and Working Politically: What Does It Mean, Why is It Important and How Do You Do It? GSDRC, Birmingham.
  • Leite, N., 2017. Reinvigoration of Somali Traditional Justice Through Inclusive Conflict Approaches, Accord, Durban. https://www.accord.org.za/conflict-trends/reinvigoration-somali-traditional-justice-inclusive-conflict-resolution-approaches/
  • Levy, B., 2014. Working with the Grain: Integrating Governance and Growth in Development Strategies. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  • Luckham, R., 2009. Introduction: Transforming Security and Development in an Unequal World. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford.
  • Luckham, R. and T. Kirk, 2013a. ‘The Two Faces of Security in Hybrid Political Orders: A Framework for Analysis and Research’. International Journal of Security and Development 2(2), 1–30.
  • Luckham, R. and T. Kirk, 2013b. ‘Understanding Security in the Vernacular in Hybrid Political Contexts: A Critical Survey’. Conflict, Security and Development 13(3), 339–359.
  • Lund, C., 2001. ‘Twilight Institutions: Public Authority and Local Politics in Africa.’ Development and Change 37(4), 685–705.
  • Mac Ginty, R., 2008. ‘Indigenous Peace-Making versus the Liberal Peace. Cooperation and Conflict’. Journal of the Nordic International Studies Association 43(2), 139–163.
  • Mahmud, H. S., 2013. Writer Calls for National Dialogue in Somali Justice Reforms. BBC Monitoring Africa, London.
  • Mallett, R., J. Hagen-Zanker, R. Slater and M. Duvendack, 2012. ‘The Benefits and Challenges of Using Systematic Reviews in International Development Research’. Journal of Development Effectiveness 4(3), 445–455.
  • Mariani, B., 2022. ‘China’s Engagement in Conflict and Post-Conflict Settings: The Quest for Stability’. (PeaceRep Report: Global Transitions Series). PeaceRep, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.
  • Marquette, H. and C. Peiffer, 2015. Corruption and Collective Action. Development Leadership Program, Birmingham.
  • McCullough, A. and M. Saed, 2017. Gatekeepers, Elders and Accountability in Somalia. Overseas Development Institute, London.
  • Mekennon, D. R., 2015. ‘Patterns of Legal Mixing in Eritrea: Examining the Impact of Customary Law, Islamic Law, Colonial Law, Socialist Law, and Authoritarian Revolutionary Dogma’. In Mixed Legal Systems, East and West, ed. V. Palmer. Taylor and Francis Group, London, 151–166.
  • Midgley, T., S. El Taraboulsi-McCarthy, R. Ahmed and A. Carr, 2022. ‘Beyond Box-Ticking: How Conflict Sensitivity Can Help Bring About a More Equitable Aid System. Development in Practice’. Development in Practice 33(5), 633–638.
  • Moe, L. W. and M. V. Simojoki, 2013. ‘Custom, Contestation and Co-Operation: Peace and Justice Promotion in Somaliland’. Conflict, Security and Development 13(4), 393–416.
  • Mydlak, R., 2019. Engagement of Somali Customary Institutions in Justice Programs. Forcier, Washington, DC.
  • Nathan, L., 2007. No Ownership, No Commitment: A Guide to Local Ownership of Security Sector Reform. Global Facilitation Network for Security Sector Reform, University of Birmingham, Birmingham.
  • Oosterveld, W. and R. Galand, 2012. ‘Justice Reform, Security Sector Reform and Local Ownership’. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 4(1), 194–209.
  • Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, 2007. The OECD DAC Handbook on Security Sector Reform. Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris.
  • PCEF, 2019. Perceptions Assessment/mid-Term Evaluation for ‘The Time is Now - Strengthening Police Accountability and Access to Justice in Somalia’. DRC, Copenhagen.
  • Police Accountability Working Group, 2019. Police Accountability Working Group Meeting: SGBV and Gender-Inclusive Justice Provision. DDG East Africa Office, Nairobi.
  • Popay, J., H. Roberts, A. Sowden, M. Petticrew, L. Arai, M. Rodgers, N. Britten, K. Roen and S. Duffy, 2006. Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews: A Product from the ESRC Methods Programme. University of Lancaster, Bailrigg.
  • Pratt, M., 2009. ‘From the Editors - for the Lack of Boilerplate: Tips on Writing Up (And Reviewing) Qualitative Research’. Academy of Management Journal 52(5), 856–862.
  • Ramalingam, B., M. Laric and J. Primrose, 2014. From Best Practice to Best Fit: Understanding and Navigating Wicked Problems in International Development. Overseas Development Institute, London.
  • Richmond, O. P., 2009. ‘Becoming Liberal, Unbecoming Liberalism: Liberal-Local Hybridity via the Everyday as a Response to the Paradoxes of Liberal Peacebuilding’. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 3(3), 324–344.
  • Rocha Menocal, A., 2016. Social Movements. GSDRC Professional Development Reading Pack No . 50. University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
  • Rohwerder, B., 2016. Lessons Learned from Security-Related Programming in Stabilisation and Conflict-Affected Contexts. GSDRC, Birmingham.
  • Saferworld, 2019. Increasing Women’s Participation in Community-Based Security Structures. Saferworld, London.
  • Saferworld, 2020. Sustainable Community Approaches to Peacebuilding in Securitised Environments: Case Study of Somalia. Saferworld, London.
  • Schroeder, U. C. and F. Chappuis, 2014. ‘New Perspectives on Security Sector Reform: The Role of Local Agency and Domestic Politics’. International Peacekeeping 21(2), 133–148.
  • Sedra, M., 2018. ‘Adapting Security Sector Reform to Ground-Level Realities: The Transition to a Second-Generation Model’. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12(1), 48–63.
  • Sen, A., 1999. Development as Freedom. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  • Snilstveit, B., S. Oliver and M. Vojtkova, 2012. ‘Narrative Approaches to Systematic Review and Synthesis of Evidence for International Development Policy and Practice’. Journal of Development Effectiveness 4(3), 409–429.
  • Soyden, 2015. District Peace Committee Assessment. Soyden, Mogadishu.
  • Stewart, F., 2004. ‘Development and Security’. Conflict, Security and Development 4(3), 261–288.
  • Stewart, R., 2014. ‘Changing the World One Systematic Review at a Time: A New Development Methodology for Making a Difference’. Development Southern Africa 31(4), 581–590.
  • Tait, S., T. Probert and Gossar Abdirahman Maalim, 2019. Community-Police Dialogue Cooperation in Somalia. Lessons Learnt. Danish Demining Group, Copenhagen.
  • UNDP, 2009. Traditional Elders in Puntland Firm Up on Human Rights. UNDP, New York.
  • UNDP, 2017a. Programme Annual Progress Report Period 1 January-31 December 2017. UNDP, New York.
  • UNDP, 2017b. Programme Annual Progress Report Period Quarter 1 2017. UNDP, New York.
  • UNDP, 2017c. Programme Quarterly Progress Report. UNDP, New York.
  • Vargas Simojoki, M., 2011. Enhancing Legal Empowerment. Working with Customary Justice Systems: Post-Conflict and Fragile States. Working Paper Series 2. Unlikely Allies: Working with Traditional Leaders to Reform Customary Law in Somalia. International Development Law Organization, Rome.
  • Verweijenaand, J. and V. Van Bockhaven, 2020. ‘Revisiting Colonial Legacies in Knowledge Production on Customary Authority in Central and East Africa’. Journal of Eastern African Studies 14(1), 1–23.
  • Waddington, H., H. White, B. Snilstveit, J. G. Hombrados, M. Vojtkova, P. Davies, A. Bhavsar, J. Eyers, T. P. Koehlmoos, M. Petticrew, J. C. Valentine and P. Tugwell, 2012. ‘How to Do a Good Systematic Review of Effects in International Development: A Tool Kit’. Journal of Development Effectiveness 4(3), 359–387.
  • Wiuff Moe, L., 2011. ‘Hybrid and ‘Everyday’ Political Ordering: Constructing and Contesting Legitimacy in Somaliland’. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 43(63), 143–177.
  • Wiuff Moe, L. and M. Vargas, 2012. ‘Supporting Local Peace Building and Access to Justice: Traditional Leaders as Drivers for Change?’. In Reflections and Lessons of Somaliland’s Two Decades of Sustained Peace, Statebuilding and Democratization, ed. F. Mohammed. Soradi, Hargeisa, 53–69.
  • Wiuff Moe, L. and M. Vargas Simojoki, 2013. ‘Custom, Contestation and Co-Operation: Peace and Justice Promotion in Somaliland’. Conflict, Security & Development 13(4), 393–416.
  • Wong, G., T. Greenhalgh, G. Westhorp, J. Buckingham and R. Pawson, 2013. ‘RAMESES Publication Standards: Realist Syntheses’ . BMC Medicine 11(21), 1–14.
  • The World Bank, 2011. World Development Report 2011: Conflict, Security and Development. The World Bank, Washington, DC.
  • The World Bank, 2017. World Development Report 2017: Governance and the Law. The World Bank, Washington, DC.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.