Abstract
School integration (desegregation) was introduced in Israeli junior high schools in 1968 with the aim of increasing educational equality and decreasing (Jewish) ethnic divides. While never officially abandoned, a de facto retreat from this policy has been observed since the early 1990s, despite the voluminous research that revealed its positive, though moderate, educational outcomes. This shift in educational emphases reflected profound societal changes, fed by global neo-liberal trends and educational consumerism, which research-based arguments supporting integration were too weak to resist. The ascent and waning of school integration in Israel provide an instructive case for analysing the interconnection of educational policy, educational research, and societal changes, demonstrating the weakness of research in sustaining educational policy in the face of counteracting social and political developments.
Notes
1. We are aware that didactic fit may be influenced by teaching methods and pedagogical style, no less than by class homogeneity. Our argument about didactic fit rests however on the notion that conventional, frontal teaching is prevalent in most schools.
2. Findings regarding differential effects for high and low achievers are inconclusive. Many studies show an academic gain of low achievers that outweighs the loss of high achievers (e.g., Coleman et al., Citation1966; Leiter, Citation1983; Dar & Resh, Citation1986b; Terwel & Van den Eeden, Citation1992; Hoffer, Citation1992; Aitkin & Zozovsky, Citation1994; Zimmer & Toma, Citation2000; Hochschild & Scovronick, Citation2003; Schofield, Citation2010). Other studies point to zero-sum outcomes (e.g., Willms, Citation1986; Willms & Chen, Citation1989; Rumberger & Palardy, Citation2005). Kerckhoff (Citation1986) have found enriched composition benefiting low achievers more than the high achievers in reading but vice versa in mathematics. A recent British ethnographic study provides an interesting testimony in this regard. White middle class parents who have intentionally sent their children to learn in a comprehensive school together with disadvantaged white and black children, expressed satisfaction with their children’s attainments, including their academic achievement (Reay et al., Citation2007).
3. This description refers to the Jewish students. Israeli Arab pupils, about 20% of the population, are instructed in Arabic in separate Arabic schools.
4. The 1968 reform added one free compulsory year of schooling (ninth grade). In 1979, high school education of 12 years became free and the tenth grade compulsory.
5. Intentional integration was carried out at the junior high schools, but studies of ‘natural’ socioeconomic and ethnic heterogeneity at the elementary level were also included in this summary.
6. Innovative instructional practices adapted to heterogeneous classes were introduced in Israel in many schools and followed in some cases by systematic evaluative studies that disclosed mixed results (e.g., Ben Ari & Rich, Citation1992).
7. Although desegregation in the US was defined mainly in racial/ethnic terms, there is a strong argument for considering school SES as a factor (not as a control) in studying compositional effects (see, Jencks & Meyer, Citation1990; Rumberger & Palardy, Citation2005).
9. For accounts of similar developments see, for example, Schofield and Hausmann (Citation2004) and Wells et al., (Citation2005) in the US, and McGregor (Citation2009) in Australia.
Coleman
,
J. S.
,
Campbell
,
E. Q.
,
Hobson
,
C. J.
,
McPartland
,
J.
,
Mood
,
A.
,
Winfield
,
F. D.
and
York
,
R. L.
1966
.
Equality of educational opportunity
,
Washington
,
DC
:
Government Printing
.
Leiter
,
J.
1983
.
Classroom composition and achievement gains
.
Sociology of Education
,
56
:
126
–
132
.
Dar
,
Y.
and
Resh
,
N.
1986
.
Classroom intellectual composition and academic achievement
.
American Educational Research Journal
,
23
:
357
–
374
.
Terwel
,
J.
and
Van den Eeden
,
P.
1992
.
Curriculum evaluation and multilevel analysis: Effects of cooperative learning in mathematics
.
Studies in Educational Evaluation
,
18
:
133
–
148
.
Hoffer
,
T. B.
1992
.
Middle school ability grouping and student achievement in science and mathematics
.
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis
,
14
:
205
–
227
.
Aitkin
,
M.
and
Zozovsky
,
R.
1994
.
Multi-level interaction models and their use in the analysis of large scale school effectiveness studies
.
School Effectiveness and School Improvement
,
5
:
45
–
74
.
Zimmer
,
R. W.
and
Toma
,
E. F.
2000
.
Peer effects in private and public schools across countries
.
Journal of Policy Analysis and Management
,
19
:
75
–
92
.
Hochschild
,
J.
and
Scovronick
,
N.
2003
.
The American dream and the public schools
,
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Schofield
,
J. W.
2010
.
International evidence on ability grouping with curriculum differentiation and the achievement gap in secondary schools
.
Teachers College Record
,
112
:
1492
–
1528
.
Willms
,
J. D.
1986
.
Social class segregation and its relationship to pupil’s examination results in Scotland
.
American Sociological Review
,
51
:
224
–
241
.
Willms
,
J. D.
and
Chen
,
M.
1989
.
The effects of ability grouping on the ethnic achievement gap in Israeli elementary schools
.
American Journal of Education
,
97
:
237
–
257
.
Rumberger
,
R. W.
and
Palardy
,
G. J.
2005
.
Does segregation still matter? The impact of student composition on academic achievement in high school
.
Teacher College Record
,
107
:
1999
–
2045
.
Kerckhoff
,
A. C.
1986
.
Effect of ability grouping in British secondary schools
.
American Sociological Review
,
51
:
842
–
858
.
Reay
,
D.
,
Hollingworth
,
S.
,
Williams
,
K.
,
Crozier
,
G.
,
Jamieson
,
F.
,
James
,
D.
and
Beedell
,
P.
2007
.
‘A darker shade of pale?’ Whiteness, the middle classes and multi-ethnic inner city schooling
.
Sociology
,
41
:
1041
–
1058
.
Ben Ari
,
R.
and
Rich
,
Y.
1992
.
“
Meaningful participation in learning for all students in the heterogeneous class
”
. In
To be young and gifted
,
Edited by:
Klein
,
P.
and
Tennenbaum
,
A.
348
–
378
.
Norwood
,
NJ
:
Ablex Press
.
Jencks
,
Ch
and
Mayer
,
S. E.
1990
.
“
The social consequences of growing up in poor neighborhood
”
. In
Inner-city poverty in the United States
,
Edited by:
Lynn
,
L.
and
Geary
,
M. G. H.
111
–
186
.
Washington
,
DC
:
National Academy Press
.
Rumberger
,
R. W.
and
Palardy
,
G. J.
2005
.
Does segregation still matter? The impact of student composition on academic achievement in high school
.
Teacher College Record
,
107
:
1999
–
2045
.
Barr
,
R.
and
Dreeben
,
R.
1983
.
How schools work
,
Chicago
:
University of Chicago Press
.
Jencks
,
Ch
and
Mayer
,
S. E.
1990
.
“
The social consequences of growing up in poor neighborhood
”
. In
Inner-city poverty in the United States
,
Edited by:
Lynn
,
L.
and
Geary
,
M. G. H.
111
–
186
.
Washington
,
DC
:
National Academy Press
.
Wells
,
A. S.
and
Crain
,
R.
1997
.
Stepping over the color line
,
New haven
,
CT
:
Yale University Press
.
Wells
,
A. S.
and
Oakes
,
J.
1998
.
“
Tracking, detracking and the politics of educational reform: A sociological perspective
”
. In
Sociology of education: Emerging perspectives
,
Edited by:
Torres
,
C. A.
and
Mitchell
,
T. R.
158
–
180
.
Albany
,
NY
:
State University of New York Press
.
Rumberger
,
R. W.
and
Palardy
,
G. J.
2005
.
Does segregation still matter? The impact of student composition on academic achievement in high school
.
Teacher College Record
,
107
:
1999
–
2045
.
Opdenakker
,
M.
and
van Damme
,
J.
2007
.
Do school context, student composition and school leadership affect school practice and outcomes in secondary education?
.
British Educational Research Journal
,
33
:
179
–
206
.
Schofield
,
J. W.
and
Hausmann
,
L. R. M.
2004
.
The conundrum of school desegregation: Positive student outcomes and waning support
.
University of Pittsburgh Law Review
,
66
:
83
–
111
.
Wells, A. S., Holme, J. J., Revilla, A. J. & Atanda, A. K. (2005) How society failed school desegregation policy: Looking past the schools to understand them, in: R. Floden (Ed.) Review of Research in Education, 28, 47–100.
McGregor
,
G.
2009
.
Education for (whose) success? Schooling in the age of neo-liberalism
.
British Journal of Sociology of Education
,
30
:
345
–
348
.