Documenting the Endangered North Atlantic Right Whale: Policies, Conservation Efforts, and Stakeholders Depicted in Entangled and Last of the Right Whales

Abstract

Wildlife documentaries are a form of environmental media widely used in public engagement around sustainability and conservation issues, including biodiversity loss. Two recently released wildlife documentaries, Entangled (2020) and Last of the Right Whales (2021), are the first to tell stories focused on the critically endangered North Atlantic right whale (NARW) through film, despite the species having been imperiled for more than a century and experts sounding the alarm about the population’s decline for decades. While whales are highly regarded worldwide and their conservation has strong public support, the NARW case study is a complicated one due not only to biological and ecological challenges, but also to sociopolitical ones. Without drastic policy actions and changes to industry practices throughout its migratory range, the NARW may disappear within decades, becoming the first great whale species to reach extinction since the industrial whaling era. In this article we address a gap in current environmental media and documentary studies by engaging critically with Entangled and Last of the Right Whales and considering them within the socioecological contexts they showcase and aim to influence. Our findings indicate that these two films share an important environmental problem with their viewers but fail to overcome some important pitfalls that limit the ability of environmental films to achieve collective action and policy change. We use this case study to highlight opportunities and challenges associated with wildlife documentaries more broadly, specifically, their role in biodiversity conservation in the Anthropocene. We conclude with opportunities for future interdisciplinary research and collaborative practice that can help wildlife films to achieve more than accolades for filmmakers and mere general awareness of conservation challenges.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1 KTA Davies and SW Brillant, ‘Mass Human-Caused Mortality Spurs Federal Action to Protect Endangered North Atlantic Right Whales in Canada’ (2019) 104 Marine Policy 157.

2 HM Pettis et al, North Atlantic Right Whale Consortium 2019 Annual Report Card https://hdl.handle.net/1912/29593; HM. Pettis et al, North Atlantic Right Whale Consortium 2021 Annual Report Card, https://hdl.handle.net/1912/29595.

3 M Shriver-Rice and H Vaughan, ‘What Is Environmental Media Studies?’ (2020) 1 Journal of Environmental Media 3.

4 ST Turvey and JJ Crees, ‘Extinction in the Anthropocene’ (2019) 29 Current Biology R982.

5 CN Johnson et al, ‘Biodiversity Losses and Conservation Responses in the Anthropocene’ (2017) 356 Science 270.

6 IPBES, Global Assessment Report on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (Bonn, IPBES, 2019).

7 DA Farber, ‘Separated at Birth? Addressing the Twin Global Crises of Biodiversity and Climate Change’ (2015) 42 Ecology Law Quarterly 841.

8 H-O Pörtner et al, Scientific Outcome of the IPBES-IPCC Co-Sponsored Workshop on Biodiversity and Climate Change (Bonn, IPBES, 2021).

9 EA Gregg et al, ‘Biodiversity Conservation Cannot Afford COVID-19 Communication Bungles’ (2021) 36 Trends in Ecology & Evolution 879; MB. Reamer, ‘Communicating Ocean and Human Health Connections: An Agenda for Research and Practice’ (2020) 10 Frontiers in Public Health 1.

10 A Ivakhiv, ‘Green Film Criticism and Its Futures’ (2008) 15 Interdisciplinary Studies in Literature and Environment 1.

11 WJ Sutherland, ‘Managing Habitats and Species; in WJ Sutherland (ed), Conservation Science and Action (Oxford, Blackwell Publishing, 1998) 202.

12 B Nichols, Introduction to Documentary (3rd ed, Bloomington, Indiana University Press, 2017).

13 B Karlin and J Johnson, ‘Measuring Impact: The Importance of Evaluation for Documentary Film Campaigns’ (2011) 14 M/C Journal 1; RC Patel, Filmmaking as a Tool for Social Impact: Modeling Documentary to Create Change, https://scholarworks.montana.edu/xmlui/handle/1/14030/.

14 K Howlett et al, ‘Wildlife Documentaries Present a Diverse, but Biased, Portrayal of the Natural World’ (2023) 5 People and Nature 633; Shriver-Rice and Vaughan (n3).

15 S Pollo, M Graziano and C Giacoma, ‘The Ethics of Natural History Documentaries’ (2009) 77 Animal Behaviour 1357.

16 Phillip D. Duncan, ‘(Science) Fiction: Genre Hybridization in Jacques-Yves Cousteau and Louis Malle’s The Silent World (1956)’ (2018) 46 Journal of Popular Film and Television 108.

17 F Dunaway, Seeing Green: The Use and Abuse of American Environmental Images (Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2018).

18 C Musser, ‘Trauma, Truth and the Environmental Documentary’ in A Marine (ed) Eco-Trauma Cinema (New York, Routledge, 2015) 46.

19 B Smaill, ‘Emotion, Argumentation, and Documentary Traditions: Darwin’s Nightmare and The Cove’ in AW von Mossner (ed) Moving Environments: Affect, Emotion, Ecology, and Film (Ontario, Wilfrid Laurier University Press, 2014) 106.

20 A De Lara, JA García-Avilés and G Revuelta, ‘Online Video on Climate Change: A Comparison between Television and Web Formats’ (2017) 16 Journal of Science Communication A04.

21 JPG Jones et al, ‘Nature Documentaries and Saving Nature: Reflections on the New Netflix Series Our Planet’ (2019) 1 People and Nature 420.

22 D Ingram, Green Screen: Environmentalism and Hollywood Cinema (Exeter, University of Exeter Press, 2010).

23 P Banchero, TA Rector and J VanBallenberghe, ‘Best Practices in Climate Change Communication as Applied to an Informal Education Documentary about Alaska’ (2021) 69 Journal of Geoscience Education 138.

24 MJ Williamson et al, Ethical Considerations in Natural History Film Production and the Need for Industry-Wide Best Practice’ (2022) 34 Global Ecology and Conservation 34; Pollo, Graziano and Giacoma (n15).

25 R Dingwall and M Aldridge, ‘Television Wildlife Programming as a Source of Popular Scientific Information: A Case Study of Evolution’ (2006) 15 Public Understanding of Science 131.

26 E Louson, ‘Taking Spectacle Seriously: Wildlife Film and the Legacy of Natural History Display’ (2018) 31 Science in Context 15.

27 Ivakhiv (n10).

28 Williamson (n24).

29 D Bousé, ‘Are Wildlife Films Really “Nature Documentaries”?’ (1998) 15 Critical Studies in Mass Communication 116; M Curtin, Packaging Reality : The Influence of Fictional Forms on the Early Development of Television Documentary (Columbia, SC, Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication, 1993); A Hill, Restyling Factual TV: Audiences and News, Documentary and Reality Genres (New York, Routledge, 2007).

30 J Hultgren, ‘21st Century American Environmental Ideologies: A Re-Evaluation’ (2018) 23 Journal of Political Ideologies 54.

31 Howlett (n14).

32 C Molloy, Popular Media and Animals (New York, Palgrave Macmillan, 2011).

33 S Cubitt, Eco Media (Amsterdam, Rodopi, 2005).

34 Jones (n21); E Zemanek, ‘Between Fragility and Resilience: Ambivalent Images of Nature in Popular Documentaries with David Attenborough’ (2022) 9 The Anthropocene Review 139.

35 Molloy (n32); T Van Dooren, A World in a Shell: Snail Stories for a Time of Extinctions (Boston, MIT Press, 2022).

36 Ivakhiv (n10).

37 S Rust, S Monani, and S Cubitt (eds), Ecocinema Theory and Practice (New York, Routledge, 2012), 161–80.

38 Banchero, Rector, and VanBallenberghe (n23); W Finkler and LS Davis, ‘Filmmaking, Affective Communication, and the Construction of Tourism Imaginaries: Putting The Wow Into Sustainable Whale Watching’ (2022) 22 Tourism Culture & Communication 205.

39 C Mazzoldi et al, ‘From Sea Monsters to Charismatic Megafauna: Changes in Perception and Use of Large Marine Animals’ (2019) 14 PLoS ONE e0226810; D Reiss et al, ‘Dolphins in Popular Literature and Media’ (2006) 14 Society & Animals 321; MB Reamer, ‘Recovery of the Eastern North Pacific Gray Whale: A Case Study’ (2022) 25 Journal of International Wildlife Law and Policy 201.

40 A Peace, ‘Loving Leviathan: The Discourse of Whale-Watching in Australian Ecotourism,’ in J Knight (ed), Animals in Person (New York, Routledge, 2020) 191.

41 Finkler and Davis (n38).

42 GD Bossart, ‘Marine Mammals as Sentinel Species for Oceans and Human Health’ (2011) 48 Veterinary Pathology 676.

43 DJ McCauley, ‘The Future of Whales in Our Anthropocene Ocean’ (2023) 25 Science Advances eadi7604.

44 W Naylor and ECM. Parsons, ‘An Online Survey of Public Knowledge, Attitudes, and Perceptions Toward Whales and Dolphins, and Their Conservation’ (2018) 5 Frontiers in Marine Science 153.

45 M Bellanger et al, ‘Addressing Marine and Coastal Governance Conflicts at the Interface of Multiple Sectors and Jurisdictions’ (2020) 7 Frontiers in Marine Science 544440.

46 H Omura, ‘North Pacific Right Whale’ (1958) 13 Scientific Reports of the Whales Research Institute 1; CJ Pfeiffer, ‘Whale Lice,’ in WF Perrin, B Würsig and JGM Thewissen (eds), Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals (Amsterdam, Elsevier, 2009) 1220.

47 RD Kenney, ‘Right Whales’ in Perrin, Würsig and Thewissen (n46) 962.

48 SD Kraus et al, ‘Recent Scientific Publications Cast Doubt on North Atlantic Right Whale Future’ (2016) 3 Frontiers in Marine Science 137; Pettis (n2).

49 JT Jenkins, A History of the Whale Fisheries : From the Basque Fisheries of the Tenth Century to the Hunting of the Finner Whale at the Present Date (London, H.F. & G. Witherby, 1921); JM Savelle and N Kishigami–, ‘Anthropological Research on Whaling : Prehistoric, Historic and Current Contexts’, https://minpaku.repo.nii.ac.jp/records/2444.

50 PB Best et al, ‘Mortalities of Right Whales and Related Anthropogenic Factors in South African Waters, 1963-1998,’ (2020) 21 Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 171; ECM Parsons, An Introduction to Marine Mammal Biology and Conservation (Burlington, Mass, Jones & Bartlett Learning, 2013).

51 Kraus (n48); Erin Meyer-Gutbrod et al, ‘Ocean Regime Shift Is Driving Collapse of the North Atlantic Right Whale Population’ (2021) 34 Oceanography 22.

52 RM Pace, PJ Corkeron and SD Kraus, ‘State-Space Mark-Recapture Estimates Reveal a Recent Decline in Abundance of North Atlantic Right Whales’ (2017) 21 Ecology and Evolution 8730; Pettis (n2).

53 F Christiansen et al, ‘Population Comparison of Right Whale Body Condition Reveals Poor State of the North Atlantic Right Whale’ (2020) 640 Marine Ecology Progress Series 1; P Corkeron et al, ‘The Recovery of North Atlantic Right Whales, Eubalaena Glacialis, Has Been Constrained by Human-Caused Mortality’ (2018) 5 Royal Society Open Science 180892; MJ Moore, ‘Policy Enabling North Atlantic Right Whale Reproductive Health Could Save the Species’ (2023) 80 ICES Journal of Marine Science 237: MJ Moore et al, ‘Assessing North Atlantic Right Whale Health: Threats, and Development of Tools Critical for Conservation of the Species’ (2021) 143 Diseases of Aquatic Organisms 205.

54 Reamer (n39); AN Zerbini et al, ‘Assessing the Recovery of an Antarctic Predator from Historical Exploitation,’ (2019) 6 Royal Society Open Science 190368.

55 Reamer ibid.

56 J Fisher, ‘Managing Environmental Conflict’ in PT Coleman, M Deutsch, and EC Marcus (eds), The Handbook of Conflict Resolution: Theory and Practice (3rd ed, San Francisco, Jossey-Bass, 2014), 230; SM Redpath et al, ‘Understanding and Managing Conservation Conflicts’ (2013) 28 Trends in Ecology & Evolution 100.

57 J Weatherwax, ‘The Right to Live: How North Atlantic Right Whales Are Going Extinct Despite Environmental Protections’ (2021) 52 University of Miami Inter-American Law Review 237.

58 Reamer (n39).

59 Convention for the Regulation of Whaling (adopted 24 September 1931, entered into force 16 January 1935) 155 LNTS 349.

60 International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling (ICRW) (adopted 2 December 1946, entered into force 10 November 1948) 161 UNTS 72.

61 Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (adopted 3 March 1973, entered into force 1 July 1975, amended 30 April 1983) 993 UNTS 243.

62 J Myer Valenti, ‘When Environmental Documentary Films Are Journalism’ in DB Sachsman and J Myer Valenti (eds), Routledge Handbook of Environmental Journalism (New York, Routledge, 2020) 99.

63 LL Putnam and M Shoemaker, ‘Changes in Conflict Framing in the News Coverage of an Environmental Conflict’ (2007) 1 Journal of Dispute Resolution 167.

64 S Schwarze, ‘Environmental Melodrama’ (2006) 92 Quarterly Journal of Speech 239.

65 S Schwarze et al, ‘Environmental Melodrama, Coal, and the Politics of Sustainable Energy in The Last Mountain’ (2014) 17 International Journal of Sustainable Development 108.

66 Ibid 111.

67 L McClenachan, NR Record and J Waller, ‘How Do Human Actions Affect Fisheries? Differences in Perceptions between Fishers and Scientists in the Maine Lobster Fishery’ (2022) 7 FACETS 174.

68 Schwarze (n62).

69 P Boyle, ‘Public Problems, Values, and Choices’ [2001] Popular Government 18.

70 PA Loring, ‘The Political Ecology of Gear Bans in Two Fisheries: Florida’s Net Ban and Alaska’s Salmon Wars,’ (2017) 18 Fish and Fisheries 94.

71 JA Duvall, The Environmental Documentary: Cinema Activism in the Twenty-First Century (New York, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017).

72 Williamson (n 24).

73 E Louson, ‘Performing Authenticity: The Making‐of Documentary in Wildlife Film’s Blue‐chip Renaissance’ (2021) 3 People and Nature 1147.

74 T Milstein, ‘The Performer Metaphor: “Mother Nature Never Gives Us the Same Show Twice”‘(2016) 10 Environmental Communication 227.

75 T Milstein, ‘Nature Identification: The Power of Pointing and Naming’ (2011) 5 Environmental Communication 3.

76 Moore (n53).

77 J Metag and MS Schäfer, ‘Audience Segments in Environmental and Science Communication: Recent Findings and Future Perspectives’ (2018) 12 Environmental Communication 995.

78 RJ Brulle, ‘From Environmental Campaigns to Advancing the Public Dialog: Environmental Communication for Civic Engagement’ (2010) 4 Environmental Communication 82; S Gregory, ‘Human Rights Made Visible: New Dimensions to Anonymity, Consent, and Intentionality’ in M McLagan and Y McKee, Sensible Politics: The Visual Culture of Nongovernmental Activism (Cambridge, MA, Zone Books, 2012) 551; A Zerfass et al, ‘Strategic Communication: Defining the Field and Its Contribution to Research and Practice’ (2018) 12 International Journal of Strategic Communication 487.

79 LD Jenkins, ‘Power, Politics, and Culture of Marine Conservation Technology in Fisheries’ (2022) 36 Conservation Biology e13855.

80 Dunaway (n17).

81 Reamer (n39).

82 G Lakoff, ‘Why It Matters How We Frame the Environment’ (2010) 4 Environmental Communication 70.

83 Brulle (n78); Gregory (n78); S Gregory, ‘The Participatory Panopticon and Human Rights: WITNESS’s Experience Supporting Video Advocacy and Future Possibilities’ in McLagan and McKee (n75) 517.