Gradually and then suddenly: the effects of Russia’s attacks on the evolution of cybersecurity policy in Lithuania

References

• Banta, Benjamin R. 2020. “International Cyberpolitics.” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics, Online publication, September 28. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190846626.013.553.
   Google Scholar
• Barichella, Arnault. 2022. Cyberattacks in Russia’s Hybrid War Against Ukraine. Paris: Jacques Delors Institute. Policy paper No. 281, September.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2008a. “The Politician Proposes to Establish a NATO Energy Security Centre in Lithuania,” February 26.
   Google Scholar
• BNS 2008b. “Internet Invaders Paralyzed more than 300 Lithuanian Websites,” June 30.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2008c. “The Government is Called Upon to Respond More Quickly to Cyberattacks against Lithuania,” July 2.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2008d. “It is Necessary to Analyse Lithuania’s Security Policy and Evaluate the Intensified Threats to my Politicians,” August 21.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2008e. “Cyberattacks will Repeat in the Future, Specialists Say,” September 25.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2011a. “Strategy: An External Threat to Lithuania – Economic and Energy Dependence, Internal – Uneven Social Development,” April 4.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2011b. “The MoI has Developed the First National Cybersecurity Program,” May 30.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2011c. “The President Realistically Considers the Idea of a Joint Baltic-Nordic cyber Defense Force,” June 17.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2011d. “Experts have Clarified the Largest String of Cyberattacks in History,” August 4.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2011e. “U.S. Intelligence Blames China and Russia for Aggressive Cyber Espionage,” November 4.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2011f. “CNSD Discussed the Implementation of the Electronic Information Security (Cybersecurity) Development Program 2011–2019,” CNSD Press Release, December 21.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2012a. “Cybersecurity in Lithuania: Between Political Declarations, Non-Existent Funding and Growing Threats,” January 29.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2012b. “An International Cybersecurity Seminar is Held at the Army Combat Training Centre,” April 17.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2012c. “The first European Week Discussion ‘Cybersecurity and Electronic Information Security in Today’s Europe’ Took Place in the Seimas,” CNSD Press Release, May 3.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2012d. “The Seimas Committee Discussed the Legal Regulation of Cybersecurity Policy,” Press Release of the ICPD, December 5.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013a. “Cyber and Energy Security – Lithuania's Priority.” LRP Press Service, February 2.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013b. “During the EU Presidency, Lithuania May Not Ensure Cybersecurity, Says the Chairman of the CNSD,” May 23.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013c. “It is Proposed to Put the Issue of Cyberattacks on the Agenda of the Seimas Committee,” May 24.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013d. “Internet Media Representatives: More State Aid is Needed to Contain Cyberattacks,” May 29.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013e. “Attack on delfi.lt Highlighted the Country’s Weak Digital Security – E. Lucas,” May 30.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013f. “In the Presidency – A Meeting on Cybersecurity Issues,” President’s Press Service, June 3.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013g. “Information Protection must be Carried Out Promptly and in a Coordinated Manner,” President’s Press Service, June 4.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013h. “Auditor General has Indicated the Weak Points of Information Systems,” Press Release of the National Audit Office of Lithuania, June 4.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013i. “Cybersecurity will be Given Extra Attention,” Government Chancellery Press Service, June 26.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013j. “The Cybersecurity Advisory Council has Started Its Activities,” July 8.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2013k. “It is Necessary to Deal with the Issues of the Emergency Response Centre and Cyberattacks - President (Supplemented),” December 10.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014a. “Ukraine has Become the Target of a Cyberattack,” March 8.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014b. “Against Cyberattacks – A New Law (Media),” March 13.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014c. “Even Open Aggression Does Not Force the State Security Department to Undertake Effective Threat Prevention – President,” March 27.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014d. “The Parties Promise to Better Fund Defence, to Seek the Permanent Presence of U.S. Troops (Supplemented),” March 29.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014e. “Lithuania Alone Cannot Contain Complex Cyberattacks, Says MoD Representative,” April 30.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014f. “MoD Proposes to Establish a National Cyber Security Centre,” June 8.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014g. “The President Urges the Government to Combat the Threats of Russia and Populism (to be elaborated),” August 26.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2014j. “The Cybersecurity Centre Will Not Guarantee Absolute Security, Specialists Say,” September 17.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2015a. “A Tenth of the Websites of State Bodies are Vulnerable – Head of the Cybersecurity Centre,” June 11.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2015b. “National Audit Office: Cybersecurity in the Public Sector is mediocre,” Press Release of the State Control, December 16.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2016a. “Committee of Information Society Development has made a Decision on the National Audit Office Report ‘Cybersecurity Environment in Lithuania’,” press release of the Committee Bureau, April 6.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2016b. “Report by Artūras Paulauskas, Chairman of the Seimas CNSD: Lithuania does not have a Coordinated Cyber Defence,” CNSD press release, June 13.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2016c. “National Security is Threatened by 5 percent of Hackers’ Attacks.” R Černiauskas”), September 29.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2016d. “The Government’s contribution to cybersecurity is missing, says the President,” December 21.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017a. “Minister R. Karoblis will Create an Agency to Take Care of Military Procurement – BNS interviews,” January 10.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017b. “G, Jeglinskas and E. Kerza are Appointed Vice-Ministers of National Defence,” February 19.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017c. “Ministry of National Defence Would Like to Take Over the Subordination of ‘Infostructure’,” April 16.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017d. “Cyber Defence – for the Security of the Country,” President’s Press Service, June 13.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017e. “A New Wave of Cyberattacks in Europe,” 27 June.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017f. “Presenting the Work Done in the Field of Cybersecurity and the Changes Planned,” August 7.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017g. “In Tallinn – Lithuania’s Proposals on Cybersecurity,” LRP Press Service, September 29.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2017h. “The Founder of the Economic Forum in Davos Invited the President to Next Year’s Event,” October 12.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2018. “Lithuania has Developed a Cybersecurity Strategy,” June 27.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2019a. “MoD: Preparing for the Practical Creation of an EU Cyber Rapid Response Team,” January 17.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2019b. “Lithuania Ranked Fourth in the Global Cybersecurity Index,” April 1.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2019c. “In the Cybersecurity Strengthening Plan – Centre in Kaunas, Early Warning Systems,” July 3.
   Google Scholar
• BNS. 2020. “The President, Who Visited the Centre for National Cybersecurity in Kaunas, Urged Not to Stop (supplemented),” January 7.
   Google Scholar
• Burton, Joe. 2015. “NATO’s Cyber Defence: Strategic Challenges and Institutional Adaptation.” Defence Studies 15 (4): 297–319. https://doi.org/10.1080/14702436.2015.1108108.
   Google Scholar
• Calvelty, Myriam D., and Andreas. Wenger. 2020. “Cyber Security Meets Security Politics: Complex Technology, Fragmented Politics, and Networked Science.” Contemporary Security Policy 41 (1): 5–32. https://doi.org/10.1080/13523260.2019.1678855
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Feldstein, Steven. 2022. “Disentangling the Digital Battlefield: How the Internet has Changed War.” War on the Rocks, Commentary, December 7. https://warontherocks.com/2022/12/disentangling-the-digital-battlefield-how-the-internet-has-changed-war/.
   Google Scholar
• Fick, Nathaniel and Miscik, Jami. 2022. Confronting Reality in Cyberspace. Foreign Policy for a Fragmented Internet. Independent Task Force Report No. 80. NY: Council on Foreign relations. https://www.cfr.org/task-force-report/confronting-reality-in-cyberspace.
   Google Scholar
• Gomez, Myguel A., and Shandler, Ryan. 2022. “Cyber Conflict and the Erosion of Trust,” Council on Foreign Relations, (blog post). September 21. https://www.cfr.org/blog/cyber-conflict-and-erosion-trust.
   Google Scholar
• Gottemoeller, Rose, Hedgecock, Kathryn, Magula, Justin and Poast, Paul. 2022. “Engaging with Emerged and Emerging Domains: Cyber, Space and Technology in the 2022 NATO Strategic Concept.” Defence Studies 22 (3): 516–524. https://doi.org/10.1080/14702436.2022.2082955.
   Google Scholar
• ITU, 2019. Global Cyber Security Index 2018. https://www.itu.int/dms_pub/itu-d/opb/str/D-STR-GCI.01-2018-PDF-E.pdf.
   Google Scholar
• Joly, Jeroen, and Friederike. Richter. 2023. “The Calm Before the Storm: A Punctuated Equilibrium Theory of International Politics.” Policy Studies Journal 51 (3): 265–282. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12478
   Google Scholar
• Kramer, Franklin D. 2023. The Sixth Domain: The Role of the Private Sector in Warfare, Washington DC: Atlantic Council. https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-research-reports/report/the-sixth-domain-the-role-of-the-private-sector-in-warfare/.
   Google Scholar
• Lin, Herbert. 2012. “Escalation Dynamics and Conflict Termination in Cyberspace”, Strategic Studies Quarterly, 15 (3): 46–70. quoted in Burton, Joe. 2015. “NATO’s cyber defence: strategic challenges and institutional adaptation”, Defence Studies, 15 (4): 297–319. https://doi.org/10.1080/14702436.2015.1108108.
   Google Scholar
• Microsoft. 2022. Digital Defense Report 2022. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/business/microsoft-digital-defense-report-2022.
   Google Scholar
• National Audit Office of Lithuania. 2009. Strategic Information Security. Preliminary Investigation Report, March 16, No. IT-P-900-1-3, Vilnius.
   Google Scholar
• National Audit Office of Lithuania. 2015. Cybersecurity Environment in Lithuania. Report, 9 December 2015, No VA-P-90-4-16.
   Google Scholar
• NCSC under the MoD. 2018. 2017 State of National Cybersecurity Report. https://www.nksc.lt/doc/NKSC_ataskaita_2017_[lt].pdf.
   Google Scholar
• President Dalia Grybauskaitė, 2016. “Annual State of the Nation Address.” https://grybauskaite.lrp.lt/lt/kalbos/metiniai-pranesimai/2016-m./25366.
   Google Scholar
• PwC. 2021. Cyber Threats 2020: A Year in Restrospect. London: Pricewaterhouse Coppers.
   Google Scholar
• Schneider, Jacqualine. 2022. “A World Without Trust. The Insidious Cyber Threat.” Foreign Affairs 101 (1): 22–31.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Seimas of the Republic of Lithuania. 2002. “Resolution on the Approval of the National Security Strategy,” May 28, No. IX-907, Vilnius.
   Google Scholar
• Seimas of the Republic of Lithuania. 2018. “Law on the Amendment of the Law on Cybersecurity of the Republic of Lithuania No XII-1428.” TAR, No. 11180. https://e-seimas.lrs.lt/portal/legalAct/lt/TAD/15e540727ac211e89188e16a6495e98c>, 2021 10 10.
   Google Scholar
• Seimas of the Republic of Lithuania. 2021. “Resolution on the Amendment of Resolution No. IX-907 of the Seimas of the Republic of Lithuania of 28 May 2002 on the Approval of the National Security Strategy,” draft, Vilnius.
   Google Scholar
• Sherman, Justin. 2022. Untangling the Russian Web: Spies, Proxies, and Spectrums of Russian Cyber Behaviour. Atlantic Council Cyber Statecraft Initiative, Issue Brief September. https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-research-reports/issue-brief/untangling-the-russian-web/.
   Google Scholar
• True, James L., Bryan D. Jones, and Frank R. Baumgartner. 2007. “Punctuated-Equilibrium Theory. Explaining Stability and Change in Public Policymaking.” In Theories of the Policy Process, edited by Paul A. Sabatier, 155–187. Boulder: Westview Press.
   Google Scholar
• Van den Berg, Bibi, and Saneke Kuipers. 2022. “Vulnerabilities and Cyberspace: A New Kind of Crises.” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Online publication, February 24. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.1604.
   Google Scholar
• Weber, Valentin. 2022. “The Benefits and Risks of Extending Weapon Deliveries to the Cyber Domain.” Lawfare, December 2. https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/benefits-and-risks-extending-weapons-deliveries-cyber-domain.
   Google Scholar
• Willet, Marcus. 2022. “The Cyber Dimension of the Russia-Ukraine War.” Survival 64 (5): 7–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/00396338.2022.2126193.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar