139
Views
1
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research Articles

Turning the Tide: What Enabled the “Defection Mutinies” of Nationalist Naval Vessels During the Chinese Civil War?

ORCID Icon
Pages 687-707 | Received 29 Mar 2022, Accepted 01 May 2023, Published online: 22 May 2023

References

  • Albrecht, H. and Ohl, D., 2016. Exit, resistance, loyalty: military behavior during unrest in authoritarian regimes. Perspectives on Politics, 14 (1), 38–52. doi:10.1017/S1537592715003217.
  • Bell, C.M. and Elleman, B., 2003. Naval mutinies in the 20th century and beyond. In: M.B. Christopher and B. Elleman, eds. Naval mutinies of the twentieth century: an international perspective. London: Routledge, 219–228.
  • Chang, L. 張力, Wu, S. 吳守成, and Tseng, C. 曾金蘭, 1998. Li Lian-chi xiansheng fangwen jilu 李連墀先生訪問紀錄 (Interview of Mr. Li Lian-chi). In: L. Chang 張力, S, Wu. 吳守成 and C. Tseng 曾金蘭, eds. Haijun renwu fangwen jilu 海軍人物訪問記錄 (Collected reminiscences of people in ROC navy). Taipei: Academia Sinica Modern History Institute, Vol. 1, 1–110.
  • Chen, H. 陈鸿源, 1995. Nanwang de jingxin dongpo de yimu 难忘的惊心动魄的一幕 (An unforgettable thrilling scene). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚 : 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of Kuomintang Troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 324–330.
  • Chinese Communist Party Central Committee Secretariat 中共中央书记处, 1997. Zhonggong zhongyang shujichu guanyu chengli guojun gongzuobu gei ge zhongyangju fenju de zhishi中共中央书记处关于成立国军工作部给各中央局分局的指示 (Chinese communist party central committee secretariat’s directive to central bureau sub-bureaus on establishing the Kuomintang army work department). In: Shun, C. 长舜, ed. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: zonghece 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 综合册 (Uprisings and surrenders of Kuomintang troops during the liberation war: combined volume). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 29.
  • Dai, X. 戴熙愉, 1995. Lin Zun shuai dier jiandui qiyi jingguo林遵率第二舰队起义经过 (How did Lin Zun led the second flotilla’s uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of Kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 508–514.
  • Deng, Z. 邓兆祥, Ma, Z. 马志安, and Hai, L. 海莲, 1995. Haijun shengya huaxinsheng—ji Deng Zhaoxiang shi zenyang zoushang geming daolu de海军生涯话新生—记邓兆祥是怎样走上革命道路的 (A new naval career: how did Deng Zhaoxiang joined the revolutionary path). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 399–411.
  • Dwyer, M., 2017. Soldiers in revolt: army mutinies in Africa. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Elleman, B., 2021. A history of the modern Chinese Navy, 1840–2020. Abingdon, Oxon; New York, NY: Routledge.
  • Epkenhans, M., 2003. Red sailors’ and the demise of the german empire, 1918. In: C.M. Bell and B. Elleman, eds. Naval mutinies of the twentieth century: an International Perspective. London: Routledge, 66–87.
  • Gao, X. 高晓星 and Shi, P. 时平, 1989. Minguo haijun de xingshuai 民国海军的兴衰 (The rise and fall of the republic of China navy). Nanjing: China Literature and History Press.
  • Grint, K., 2021. Mutiny and leadership. Oxford; New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
  • Guo, S. 郭寿生, 1995. Cong zuzhi “xin haijun she” dao cedong haifang dier jiandui qiyi从组织“新海军社”到策动海防第二舰队起义 (From organizing the “new navy society” to inciting the uprising of the second coastal defense Flotilla). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 449–455.
  • Hamby, J.E., 2002. The mutiny wagon wheel: a leadership model for mutiny in combat. Armed Forces & Society, 28 (4), 575–600. doi:10.1177/0095327X0202800404.
  • Hechter, M., Pfaff, S., and Underwood, P., 2016. Grievances and the genesis of rebellion: mutiny in the royal navy, 1740 to 1820. American Sociological Review, 81 (1), 165–189. doi:10.1177/0003122415618991.
  • Huang, W. 黄维鸿, 1995. Zuzhi guangguoting qiyi de jingguo组织光国艇起义的经过 (How Guangguo’s Uprising was Organized). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 673–678.
  • Hua, G. 华国富, Wen, R. 温瑞茂 and Jiang, T. 姜铁军, eds., 2010. Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun junshi 中国人民解放军军史 (History of the Chinese people’s liberation army). Vol. 3. Beijing: Military Science Press.
  • Johnson, J., 2021. Introducing the military mutinies and defections database (MMDD), 1945–2017. Journal of Peace Research, 58 (6), 1311–1319. doi:10.1177/00223433211020092.
  • Johnson, L., 2022. The third option: covert action and American foreign policy. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
  • Ju, Q. 鞠庆珍, 1995. Huang’anjian qiyi shimo黄安舰起义始末 (The beginning and end of the Huang’an’s uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 221–230.
  • Kalyvas, S.N. and Kocher, M.A., 2007. How “free” is free riding in civil wars?: Violence, insurgency, and the collective action Problem. World Politics, 59 (2), 177–216. doi:10.1353/wp.2007.0023.
  • Kuo, C. 郭起斌, 2020. Gui Yongqing Yu Zhanhou Haijun Chongzheng 桂永清與戰後海軍重整 (Kwei Yung-Ching and the post-war Naval reorganization). Master’s Thesis. National Central University.
  • Li, Y. 李云修, 1995. Huiyi 201 hao saoleiting qiyi回忆201号扫雷艇起义 (Remembering Minesweeper 201’s Uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 240–244.
  • Li, Z. 李作健, 1995. Cedong lianrongting qiyi jingguo策动联荣舰起义经过 (How the Lianrong’s uprising was incited). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 659–662.
  • Liang, K. 梁魁庭, 1995. Wo he wufengting yiqi zouxiang xinsheng我和舞凤艇一起走向新生 (Towards a new life with Wufeng). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of Kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 656–658.
  • Lin, H. 林亨元, 1995. Zhonggong zhongyang zhuhu qingbao jigou cedong guomindangjun haifang dier jiandui qiyi jingguo中共中央驻沪情报机构策动国民党军海防第二舰队起义经过 (How did the Chinese communist party central committee’s Shanghai intelligence agency incited the uprising of the kuomintang’s second coastal defense flotilla). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of Kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 444–448.
  • Lin, Z. 林遵, 1995. Guomindangjun haifang dier jiandui qiyi jingguo国民党军海防第二舰队起义经过 (Kuomintang navy second coastal defense flotilla’s uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of Kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 471–487.
  • Liu, J. 刘俊英, 1995. Nanwang de jiyi难忘的记忆 (Unforgettable memories). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 252–258.
  • Liu, K.K. 劉廣凱, 1994. Liu Guangkai Jiangjun Baoguo Yizhu 劉廣凱將軍報國憶注 (The memoirs of admiral Liu Kwang-Kai). Taipei: Academia Sinica Modern History Institute.
  • Liu, Z. 刘增厚, 1995. Wozai huang’anjian qiyi zhong我在黄安舰起义中 (My role in the Huang’an’s uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of Kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 236–239.
  • Ma, J. 马骏 and Guo, C. 郭诚, eds., 1995. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press.
  • McLauchlin, T., 2010. Loyalty strategies and military defection in rebellion. Comparative Politics, 42 (3), 333–350. doi:10.5129/001041510X12911363509792.
  • Murphy, P. and Coye, R., 2013. Mutiny and its bounty: leadership lessons from the age of discovery. New Haven; London: Yale University Press.
  • Nie, X. 聂锡禹, 1995. Huiyi yong’anjian qiyi 回忆永安舰起义 (Remembering Yong’an’s uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 693–696.
  • Peng, C. 彭楚材, 1995. Disan jidongting dui Zhenjiang qiyi第三机动艇队镇江起义 (The third mobile boat squadron’s uprising at Zhenjiang). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 426–434.
  • Quddus, M., Liu, J., and Butler, J., 1989. Money, prices, and causality: the Chinese hyperinflation, 1946–1949, reexamined. Journal of Macroeconomics, 11 (3), 447–453. doi:10.1016/0164-0704(89)90070-0.
  • Rose, E., 1982. The anatomy of mutiny. Armed Forces & Society, 8 (4), 561–574. doi:10.1177/0095327X8200800403.
  • Seymour, L., 2014. Why factions switch sides in civil wars: rivalry, patronage, and realignment in Sudan. International Security, 39 (2), 92–131. doi:10.1162/ISEC_a_00179.
  • Shandong Jiaodong Military District Political Department 山东胶东军区政治部, 1995. Shandong jiaodong junqu zhengzhibu guanyu cedong huang’anjian qiyi de gongzuo zongjie山东胶东军区政治部关于策动黄安舰起义的工作总结 (Shandong Jiaodong military district political department’s summary regarding the operation to incite the Huang’an’s uprising). In: Ma, J., 马骏 and Guo, C., 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 34–38.
  • Shao, L. 邵仑, 1995. Canjia dier jiandui qiyi jingguo 参加第二舰队起义经过 (My participation in the second flotilla uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, pp. 525–528.
  • Shou, X. 寿晓松, ed., 2011. Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun de bashinian 中国人民解放军的八十年 (Eighty years of the people’s liberation army). Beijing: Military Science Press.
  • Wang, N. 王内修, 1995. Haoxuejian guangrong qiyi郝穴舰光荣起义 (The Haoxue’s glorious uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 684–688.
  • Wang, Y. 王颐桢, 1995. Zhongsheng nanwang de yiye终生难忘的一页 (An unforgettable page of my life). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 276–286.
  • Wang, Z. 王子良, 1995. Shixiang xinde hangcheng驶向新的航程 (Towards a new voyage). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 231–235.
  • Wu, P. 吴平, 1995. Huiyi canyu cedong dier jiandui qiyi de jingli回忆参与策动第二舰队起义的经历 (Remembering my experience in inciting the uprising of the second flotilla). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 488–496.
  • Xie, F. 谢飞鹏, 1995. Huiyi lingfujian bufen guanbing qiyi回忆灵甫舰部分官兵起义 (Remembering the partial uprising of Lingfu personnel). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation War: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 624–630.
  • Yang, C. 杨朝顺, 1995. Cong “guangguohao” dao “shiyuehao”从“光国号”到“十月号”(From the Guangguo to October). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 679–683.
  • Yang, J. 杨进, 1995. Wo canyu cedong Lin Zun qiyi qingkuang pianduan 我参与策动林遵起义情况片断 (My role in inciting Lin Zun’s uprising). In: J. Ma 马骏 and C. Guo 郭诚, eds. Jiefang zhanzheng shiqi guomindangjun qiyi touching: haijun 解放战争时期国民党军起义投诚: 海军 (Uprisings and surrenders of kuomintang troops during the liberation war: navy). Beijing: Liberation Army Press, 468–470.
  • Yao, K. 姚開陽, 2017. 1949 Dapanjian 1949大叛艦 (Mutinies on ships of 1949). Taipei: Cangbi Publishing Company.
  • Yao, K. 姚開陽, 2020. 1949 Nian Zhonghua Minguo Haijun Jianting Panbian Yuanyin 1949年中華民國海軍艦艇叛變原因 (Reasons for the mutiny of the Republic of China navy ships in 1949. Academia Historica Journal, (64), 79–110.
  • Zebroski, R., 2003. The battleship potemkin and its discontents, 1905. In: C.M. Bell and B. Elleman, eds. Naval mutinies of the twentieth century: an international perspective. London: Routledge, 7–25.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.