Changes in China’s fiscal system in the late Qing

Bibliography

• Caizhengbu minyuan dang’an 财政部民元档案 [Archives of the Ministry of Finance in the First Year of the Republic of China]. Shanghai tushuguan 上海图书馆 [Shanghai Library]. Shanghai.
   Google Scholar
• Caizhengchu quanzong dang’an 财政处全宗档案 [Complete Archives of the Financial Department]. Diyi lishi dang’anguan 第一历史档案馆 [The First Historical Archives]. Beijing.
   Google Scholar
• Chen Feng 陈锋. “Chuantong caizheng fanshi de zhuanhuan: Cong ‘liang ru wei chu’ dao ‘liang chu zhi ru’ 传统财政范式的转换: 从‘量入为出’到‘量出制入’” [The Transformation of Traditional Financial Paradigm: From “Adjusting Expenditure According to Income” to “Adjusting Income Cccording to the Expenditure”]. Shixue jikan 史学集刊 [Collected Papers of History Studies], no. 5 (2021): 24–28.
   Google Scholar
• Chen Feng 陈锋. Qingdai caizheng zhengce yu huobi zhengce yanjiu 清代财政政策与货币政策研究 [Research on Fiscal and Monetary Policy in the Qing Dynasty]. Wuhan: Wuhan daxue chubanshe, 2008.
   Google Scholar
• Chen Hengwu 陈珩伍. Zhongguo daxue jiangyi: Zhongguo caizhengshi 中国大学讲义·中国财政史 [Lectures of China University: Financial History of China]. Lead print. N.p.
   Google Scholar
• “Chou yi yusuan juesuan zhuoshou banfa 筹议预算决算著手办法” [The Measures for Making Budget and Final Accounts]. Shengjing shibao 盛京时报 [Sheng-ching Shih-pao]. October 19, 1909, 3.
   Google Scholar
• “Dai fu yuan ni fu zhengwuchu 代抚院拟覆政务处” [Reply to the Council of Government Affairs]. In vol. 4 of Xiang fan andu chaocun 湘藩案牍钞存, 70. Taipei: Taiwan wenhai chubanshe, 1976.
   Google Scholar
• “(Duzhibu) you zou shiban yusuan qing chi jingwai ge yamen tongpan chouhua shili caijie fumi pian (度支部) 又奏试办预算请饬京外各衙门通盘筹画实力裁节浮糜片” [The Memorial of the Ministry of Finance on Experimenting Budget, Requesting the Government Offices outside of Beijing to Plan Budget and to Cut the Expenditure]. Zhengzhi guanbao 政治官报 [Political Communique], no. 866 (February 20, 1910): 13.
   Google Scholar
• “Duzhibu zou diaocha ge sheng sui churu kuanxiang zongshu zhe (bingdan) 度支部奏调查各省岁出入款项总数折 (并单) ” [The Memorial of the Ministry of Finance on the Investigation of Total Amount of Revenue and Expenditure in the Provinces]. Zhengzhi guanbao 政治官报 [Political Communique], no. 828 (January 11, 1910): 5–7.
   Google Scholar
• “Duzhibu zou qing chi ge sheng dufu qieshi zunzhao qianzou weichi yusuan banfa zhe 度支部奏请饬各省督抚切实遵照前奏维持预算办法折” [The Memorial of the Minister of Finance on Ordering the Provincial Governors to Maintain the Budget as Reported Before]. Zhengzhi guanbao 政治官报 [Political Communique], no. 1224 (March 30, 1911): 3–4.
   Google Scholar
• “Duzhibu zou shi ban Xuantong si nian quanguo yusuan shanbiao chenglan bing lichen banli qingxing zhe 度支部奏试办宣统四年全国预算缮表呈览并沥陈办理情形折” [Memorial of the Ministry of Finance on Experimental National Budget of the Fourth Year of Xuantong Reign], no. 60 (October 22, 1911). In vol. 51 of Neige guanbao 内阁官报 [Cabinet Communique], 299–301. Taipei: Taiwan wenhai chubanshe, 1965.
   Google Scholar
• “Duzhibu zou weichi yusuan shixing banfa zhe gao 度支部奏维持预算实行办法折稿” [The Memorial of the Ministry of Finance on Maintaining the Budget Practice]. Lead print version. N.p.: Jicheng tushu gongsi, 1911.
   Google Scholar
• “Duzhibu zou wei shiban quanguo yusuan niding zanxing zhangcheng bing zhuguan yusuan ge yamen shixiang shandan zhe 度支部奏为试办全国预算拟定暂行章程并主管预算各衙门事项缮单折” [Memorial of the Ministry of Finance on Making Regulations for Experimental National Budget, and for the Related Offices]. Duzhibu shiban quanguo yusuan zougao 度支部试办全国预算奏稿 [Memorials of the Ministry of Finance on Experimental National Budget]. Lead print.
   Google Scholar
• Feng Xu 冯煦. Wan zheng jiyao 皖政辑要 [Collection of Anhui Political Issues]. Anhui: Huangshan shushe, 2005.
   Google Scholar
• Gang Yi 刚毅. “Zou wei dangjin mifei lianxiang wei zui qing chi xia gesheng juxing baojia yancai kongliang yi ji yaoxu pian 奏为当今糜费练饷为最请饬下各省举行保甲严裁空粮以济要需 片” [Memorial on Ordering Provinces to Organize Baojia Militia and Cut the Military Expense to Meet Essential Demands]. Diyi lishi dang’anguan 第一历史档案馆 [First Historical Archives]. Beijing.
   Google Scholar
• Guangdong qingli caizhengju 广东清理财政局 [Guangdong Finance Bureau], ed. Guangdong quan sheng caizheng yange libi shuoming shu 广东全省财政沿革利弊说明书 [Explanations of Advantages and Disadvantages of Financial Reform of Guangdong Province]. Vol. 13. N.p., 1911.
   Google Scholar
• Guangdong sheng qingli caizhengju 广东省清理财政局 [Guangdong Provincial Finance Bureau], comp. Guangdong caizheng shuomingshu 广东财政说明书 [Instructions for Finance of Guangdong Province]. Vol. 1. N.p.: Guangdong sheng qingli caizhengju, 1911.
   Google Scholar
• Guangxi caizheng yange libi shuoming 广西财政沿革利弊说明 [The Advantages and Disadvantages of Guangxi Financial Reform]. N.p.: Guangxi sheng qingli caizhengju, 1911.
   Google Scholar
• He Hanwei 何汉威. “Qingji zhongyang yu gesheng caizheng guanxi de fansi 清季中央与各省财政关系的反思” [Reflection on the Financial Relationship between the Central and Provincial Governments in the Qing Dynasty]. Zhongyang yanjiuyuan lishi yuyan yanjiusuo jikan 中央研究院历史语言研究所集刊 [The Bulletin of Institute of Academia Sinica], no. 3 (September 2001): 597–698.
   Google Scholar
• Hubu zougao 户部奏稿 [Drafts of Memorials from the Board of Revenue]. Vol. 6. Beijing: Quanguo tushuguan wenxian weisuo fuzhi zhongxin, 2004.
   Google Scholar
• Huiyi zhengwuchu dang’an quanzong 会议政务处全宗 [Archives of the Council of Government Affairs]. Diyi lishi dang’anguan 第一历史档案馆 [The First Historical Archives]. Beijing.
   Google Scholar
• “Hubei buzhengshi Wang Naizheng zou choubei xianzheng zhuo fen huanjie deng zhe 湖北布政使王乃徵奏筹备宪政酌分缓急等折” [The Memorial of Wang Naizheng, the Commissioner of the Department of Finance of Zhejiang Province, on the Issues of Preparing for Constitutional System which should be Handled According to Its Degree of Urgency]. Zhengzhi guanbao 政治官报 [Political Communique], no. 974 (June 10, 1910): 7–11.
   Google Scholar
• “Hubu zou wei zunzhi yi zouzhe 户部奏为遵旨议奏折” [The Drafts of Memorial to the Emperors from the Board of Revenue]. In vol. 8 of Hubu zougao 户部奏稿 [Drafts of Memorials from the Board of Revenue], 3947–3948. Beijing: Quanguo tushuguan wenxian weisuo fuzhi zhongxin, 2004.
   Google Scholar
• “Hu Guang zongdu Ruicheng zou Hubei yusuan Xuantong san nian fen caizheng biaoce zhe 湖广总督瑞澂奏湖北预算宣统三年分财政表册折” [The Memorial of Ruicheng on the Sub-Fiscal Budget of Hubei Province of the third year of the Xuantong Reign]. Zhengzhi guanbao 政治官报 [Political Communique], no. 970 (June 6, 1910): 10–12.
   Google Scholar
• “Huyuan wei juzou hejian xiuzheng Xuantong san nian yusuan an yuanyou zhe 护院魏具奏核减修正宣统三年预算案缘由折” [The Memorial of Wei Ju on the Reasons for the Reduction of Budget of the Third Year of the Xuantong Reign]. Guangxi guanbao 广西官报 [Guangxi Communique], no. 98 (December 15, 1910): 485–486.
   Google Scholar
• Jing Lian 景廉 et al. “Zou wei jingchen shishi jiannan buku cunkuan fangbo daijin ji ying choubei xiangxu zhe奏为敬陈时事艰难部库存款放拨殆尽亟应筹备饷需折” [Memorial on the Urgency of Raising Military Fund Because the Treasury Is Almost Exhausted in This Difficult Time]. Diyi lishi dang’anguan 第一历史档案馆 [First Historical Archives]. Beijing.
   Google Scholar
• “Liangguang zongdu Zhang Mingqi zou banli si nian fen yusuan gaojun qingxing zhe 两广总督张鸣岐奏办理四年分预算告竣情形折” [Memorial of the Governor of Guangdong and Guangxi on the Sub-budget of the Fourth Year], September 30, 1911. Neige guanbao 内阁官报 [Cabinet Communique], vol. 50, 379–383. Taipei: Taiwan wenhai chubanshe, 1965.
   Google Scholar
• Li Deji 李德启. “Qingji neiwufu jingfei wenti 清季内务府经费问题” [The Funding of the Office of Imperial Affairs in Qing Dynasty]. Wenxian zhuankan 文献专刊 [Special Issue of Literature], 20th anniversary of Beiping National Palace Museum (1945): 7–27.
   Google Scholar
• Li Kanghui 李康惠. “Ding jingzhi yi yu guo yong shu 定经制以裕国用疏” [Memorial on Reforming the Fiscal System to Make the Country Affluent]. In vol. 1 of Huang ming jingshi wen bian 皇明经世文编 [Collection of Essays on the Ming Statecraft], compiled by Chen Zilong 陈子龙 et al., 9–10. Shanghai: Shanghai guji chubanshe, 1996.
   Google Scholar
• Liu Zenghe 刘增合. “Jia guo zhijian: Wan Qing huangshi caizheng de yujie yu guankong 家国之间:晚清皇室财政的逾界与管控” [Between the Family and Nation: the Trespassing and Control of Royal Finance in the Late Qing]. Zhongguo lishi yanjiuyuan jikan 中国历史研究院集刊 [Collection of Chinese Academy of History], no. 1 (2020): 175–234.
   Google Scholar
• Liu Zenghe 刘增合. “Qian gong hou ju: Qing ji dufu yu yusuan zhidu 前恭后倨: 清季督抚与预算制度” [Deficit: Provincial Governors and Budget System in the Qing]. Zhongyang yanjiuyuan jindaishi yanjiusuo jikan 中央研究院近代史研究所集刊 [Bulletin of the Institute of Modern History, Academia Sinica], no. 66 (December 2009): 55–97.
   Google Scholar
• Liu Zenghe 刘增合. “Taiping tianguo yundong chuqi Qingting de junfei chouji 太平天国运动初期清廷的军费筹济” [The Military Funding of the Qing Government in the Early Days of the Taiping Rebellion]. Lishi yanjiu 历史研究 [Historical Research], no. 2 (2014): 55–72.
   Google Scholar
• Liu Zenghe 刘增合. “Wan Qing bao jiang de junfei yunchou 晚清保疆的军费运筹” [The Raising of Military Funds for Border Defense in the Late Qing]. Zhongguo shehui kexue 中国社会科学 [Chinese Social Sciences], no. 3 (2019): 164–186.
   Google Scholar
• “Lun zhengfu hejian ge sheng xingzhengfei zhi fei ji 论政府核减各省行政费之非计” [On the Impracticalness of Government’s Cutting the Provincial Administrative Funds]. Shenbao 申报 [Shun-pao]. July 11, 1910, 2–3.
   Google Scholar
• Luo Yudong 罗玉东. “Guangxu chao bujiu caizheng zhi fangce 光绪朝补救财政之方策” [The Policy for the Financial Remedy in the Guangxu Reign]. Zhongguo jindai jingjishi yanjiu jikan 中国近代经济史研究集刊 [Bulletin of Modern Chinese Economic History], no. 2 (1933): 189–270.
   Google Scholar
• Meng Zhaochang 孟昭常. Gongmin bidu chubian 公民必读初编 [Citizens Should Read]. Shanghai: Shanghai yubei lixian gonghui, 1907.
   Google Scholar
• Ni Yuping 倪玉平. Cong guojia caizheng dao caizheng guojia: Qingchao xiantong nianjian de caizheng yu shehui 从国家财政到财政国家——清朝咸同年间的财政与社会 [From National Finance to a Fiscal State: Finance and Society during the Xianfeng and Tongxhi Reigns of the Qing Dynasty]. Beijing: Kexue chubanshe, 2017.
   Google Scholar
• Peng Yuxin 彭雨新. “Qingdai tianfu qiyun cunliu zhidu de yanjin 清代田赋起运存留制度的演进” [The Evolution of Transportation and Storage System of Land Tax in the Qing Dynasty]. Zhongguo jingjishi yanjiu 中国经济史研究 [Research of Chinese Economic History], no. 4 (1992): 124–133.
   Google Scholar
• Peng Yuxin 彭雨新. “Qingmo zhongyang yu gesheng caizheng guanxi 清末中央与各省财政关系” [The Financial Relations between the Central and Provincial Governments in the Late Qing]. Shehui kexue zazhi 社会科学杂志 [Journal of Social Sciences], no. 1 (1947): 83–110.
   Google Scholar
• “Qi Junzao deng zou fu zun chou Qishan daying junxiang yuanyou pian 祁寯藻等奏覆遵筹琦善大营军饷缘由片” [Memorial of Qi Junzao on the Raising of Military Fund for Qishan’s Military Camp]. In vol. 12 of Qing zhengfu zhenya taipingtianguo dang’an shiliao 清政府镇压太平天国档案史料 [Historical Records on Qing’s Suppression of Taiping Heavenly Kingdom], compiled by Zhongguo diyi lishi dang’anguan 中国第一历史档案馆 [The First Historical Archives of China], 494. Beijing: Shehui kexue wenxian chubanshe, 1994.
   Google Scholar
• Qing shi gao 清史稿 [Draft of Qing History]. Vol. 140. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju, 1977.
   Google Scholar
• Qing shi lu 清实录 [The Records of the Qing Dynasty]. Vol. 41. Photographed version. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju, 1986.
   Google Scholar
• Qingli caizheng zhangcheng jiangyi 清理财政章程讲义 [Lectures on Finance Regulations]. Lead print version. N.p., 1911.
   Google Scholar
• Shaanxi qingli caizhengju 陕西清理财政局 [Shaanxi Finance Bureau], comp. Shaanxi qingli caizheng shuomingshu 陕西清理财政说明书 [Finance Instructions for Shaanxi Province]. N.p.: Shaanxi qingli caizhengju, 1911.
   Google Scholar
• Shanghai tushuguan 上海图书馆 [Shanghai Library], comp. Wang Kangnian shiyou shuzha 汪康年师友书札 [Letters between Wang Kangnian and His Teachers and Friends]. Vol. 1. Shanghai: Shanghai guji chubanshe, 1986.
   Google Scholar
• Shanxi qingli caizhengju 山西清理财政局 [Shanxi Finance Bureau], comp. Shanxi quansheng caizheng shuomingshu 山西全省财政说明书 [Finance Instructions for Shanxi Province]. N.p.: Shanxi qingli caizhengju, 1911.
   Google Scholar
• Shen Tongsheng 沈桐生. Guangxu zhengyao 光绪政要 [The Important Government Affairs and Important Issues in the Guangxu Reign]. Taipei: Taiwan wenhai chubanshe, 1969.
   Google Scholar
• Takeshi Hamashita 滨下武志. Zhongguo jindai jingjishi yanjiu: Qing mo haiguan caizheng yu tongshang kouan shichang quan 中国近代经济史研究:清末海关财政与通商口岸市场圈 [Research on China’s Modern Economic History: Customs Finance and Treaty Port Market Circle in Late Qing]. Nanjing: Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, 2006.
   Google Scholar
• “The Structure of the Financial Institutions of the State in the Late Qing.” In The Scope of State Power in China, edited by Stuart R. Schram. London and Hong Kong: School of Oriental Studies, University of London and The Chinese University Press, 1985.
   Google Scholar
• Xue Fucheng 薛福成. “Xu Jiang chen jianshu zhi ji 叙疆臣建树之基” [The Foundation of the Achievements of Provincial Officials]. In vol. 78 of Huangchao jingshiwen xubian 皇朝经世文续编 [A Sequel to the Collection of Essays on the Qing Statecraft], compiled by Sheng Kang 盛康. Taipei: Taiwan wenhai chubanshe, 1972.
   Google Scholar
• “Zaixi lai han 载熙来函” [Letters from Zaixi]. In vol 1. of Zhang Jixin (Jiaoyun) cunzha 张集馨 (椒云) 存札 [Letters of Zhang Jixin (Jiaoyun)], 1-9. Zhongguo shehui kexueyuan jindaishi yanjiusuo tecang dang’an 中国社会科学院近代史研究所特藏档案 [Special Archives of Institute of Modern History, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences], jia 193.
   Google Scholar
• Zhang Jian 张謇. Yuji defang zizhi jingfei liding defangshui jiexian ying qing kaiguo huiyi 预计地方自治经费厘订地方税界限应请开国会议 [Calling for A Conference of National Congress to Make the Boundaries of Local Self-Governing Funds for Local Taxation]. N.p., 1910.
   Google Scholar
• “Zhi Weng Tongjue han 致翁同爵函” [A Letter to Weng Tongjue]. In vol. 1 of Weng Tonghe ji 翁同龢集 [The Collection of Weng Tonghe]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju, 2005.
   Google Scholar
• Zhou Jiamei 周家楣. Qi bu fu zhai zhengshu 期不负斋政书 [The Political Documents from Qi Bu Fu Zhai]. Taipei: Taiwan wenhai chubanshe, 1973.
   Google Scholar
• Zhou Yumin 周育民. Wan Qing caizheng yu shehui bianqian 晚清财政与社会变迁 [Financial and Social Changes in the Late Qing]. Shanghai: Shanghai renmin chubanshe, 2000.
   Google Scholar
• “Zizhengyuan diyi ci changnianhui di shi hao yichang suji lu 资政院第一次常年会第十号议场速记录” [Shorthand Record of the Tenth Annual Meeting of the Advisory Council]. In Xuantong er nian diyi ci changnianhui zizhengyuan huiyi suji lu 宣统二年第一次常年会资政院会议速记录 [The First Regular Meeting of the Advisory Council in the Second Year of Xuantong Reign] (No. 1 to 11). Lead print.
   Google Scholar
• “Zizhengyuan yusuan gu guyuanzhang Liu jun zexi shencha yusuan yanci 资政院预算股股员长刘君泽熙审查预算演词” [Liu Zexi’s Speech on Budget Audit]. Zhongguo yusuan yaolue 中国预算要略 [China Budget Review]. Beijing: Jingshi menkuang hutong yuyuan shiyin ju, 1910.
   Google Scholar